Superman vs Thor (punching contest)

As the fight happened in a canon book, it has always been canon and no amount of your crying is going to change that fact.

Originally posted by Silent Master
As the fight happened in a canon book, it has always been canon and no amount of your crying is going to change that fact.

Like I said, the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight happened in a canon book and was never retconned, which means that it's still canon.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Like I said, the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight happened in a canon book and was never retconned, which means that it's still canon.

Your opinion doesn't change the fact that the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight happened in a canon book and was never retconned.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Your opinion doesn't change the fact that the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight happened in a canon book and was never retconned.

You're arguing with a guy who thinks a sourcebook is a better source of canon than an actual in-continuity comic book. Why are you even bothering?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Your opinion doesn't change the fact that the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight happened in a canon book and was never retconned.

Originally posted by PillarofOsiris
You're arguing with a guy who thinks a sourcebook is a better source of canon than an actual in-continuity comic book. Why are you even bothering?

Originally posted by PillarofOsiris
You're arguing with a guy who thinks a sourcebook is a better source of canon than an actual in-continuity comic book. Why are you even bothering?

The sourcebook doesn't even retcon the fight, so Quan is actually arguing that his opinion trumps the comics.

Isn't that what he usually does though? His opinion>comics>movies>games.

Originally posted by Zack Fair
isn't that what he usually does though? His opinion>comics>movies>games.

He seems to treat his speculation as the highest form of canon.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Like I said, the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight happened in a canon book and was never retconned, which means that it's still canon.

ACTUALLY it's very debatable whether it was rectonned. You know that and I know that. The damn writer came out and said a very rectonned like line.. about how Thanosi can EVEN FOOL A WATCHER. I don't care enough about it cause SG has beaten everybody and anybody she has faced.. including Galactus... So Thanos or a Thanosi losing to her isn't a low feat at all and thus it's not worth arguing.. but saying it was never rectonned isn't totally true.. since it's a possibility it was..

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
ACTUALLY it's very debatable whether it was rectonned. You know that and I know that. The damn writer came out and said a very rectonned like line.. about how Thanosi can EVEN FOOL A WATCHER. I don't care enough about it cause SG has beaten everybody and anybody she has faced.. including Galactus... So Thanos or a Thanosi losing to her isn't a low feat at all and thus it's not worth arguing.. but saying it was never rectonned isn't totally true.. since it's a possibility it was..

Either quote where Marvel officially retconned the fight, or stop crying about it.

Squirrel Girl > all. Now, can we please move on?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Either quote where Marvel officially retconned the fight, or stop crying about it.

Do you also have a dunce cap on.. please define OFFICIALLY rectonned it... You do realize if a marvel writer comes along and makes the Infinity Gems actually Cosmic Cubes via narration. THAT IS THE OFFICIAL recton. So i'm unclear what you mean by OFFICIAL.

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
Do you also have a dunce cap on.. please define OFFICIALLY rectonned it... You do realize if a marvel writer comes along and makes the Infinity Gems actually Cosmic Cubes via narration. THAT IS THE OFFICIAL recton. So i'm unclear what you mean by OFFICIAL.

Pr has asked us to move on, so if you want to continue to cry over the fact that Squirrel Girl beat Thanos and the fight has never been retconned, please start a new thread.

Originally posted by Zack Fair
Isn't that what he usually does though? His opinion>comics>movies>games.

Originally posted by quanchi112
My opinion is my opinion. I never forced it down anyone's throats I simply told you why I believe this to be the case.

That's cool Quan

So IYO Sg vs Thanos is not canon, but that is IYO. Not a fact.

Same thing you do on all threads IYO. This is actually good to know because then it confirms what I have seen on most of your claims. You base your arguments in wishful thinking in other words IYO.

Gotcha! 😉

Now finally it makes sense why you make such arguments.

Originally posted by biensalsa
That's cool Quan

So IYO Sg vs Thanos is not canon, but that is IYO. Not a fact.

Same thing you do on all threads IYO. This is actually good to know because then it confirms what I have seen on most of your claims. You base your arguments in wishful thinking in other words IYO.

Gotcha! 😉

Now finally it makes sense why you make such arguments.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Pr has asked us to move on, so if you want to continue to cry over the fact that Squirrel Girl beat Thanos and the fight has never been retconned, please start a new thread.

Don't run and hide... I want to know what an OFFICIAL recton is

Pr(As in the MOD) has asked us to move on, so if you want to continue to cry over the fact that Squirrel Girl beat Thanos and the fight has never been retconned, please start a new thread.