Superman vs Thor (punching contest)

Started by Silent Master20 pages

Which doesn't prove that the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight is non-canon.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Which doesn't prove that the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight is non-canon.
I see you don't understand what the Thanos Sourcebook was for.

Again, the sourcebook doesn't prove that the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight is non-canon.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Again, the sourcebook doesn't prove that the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight is non-canon.
What is the purpose of the Sourcebook ?

Why do you keep bringing up the sourcebook, seeing as it doesn't prove that the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight is non-canon.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Why do you keep bringing up the sourcebook, seeing as it doesn't prove that the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight is non-canon.
If you won't answer my questions then you concede.

Your question has no bearing on the fact that sourcebook doesn't prove that the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight is non-canon.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Your question has no bearing on the fact that sourcebook doesn't prove that the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight is non-canon.
Yes, it does that's why you won't answer it.

At no point does the sourcebook say that the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight is non-canon.

So no, the sourcebook doesn't prove what you want it to.

Originally posted by Silent Master
At no point does the sourcebook say that the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight is non-canon.

So no, the sourcebook doesn't prove what you want it to.

Therein lies the answer. Why would the book mention a noncanon showing ? You're slow.

The fight happened in a canon book, so it's not a non-canon showing.

Originally posted by Silent Master
The fight happened in a canon book, so it's not a non-canon showing.
You just said the book should mention noncanon showings. Where is your head at ?

The Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight happened in a canon book and at no point does the sourcebook retcon it.

Originally posted by Silent Master
The Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight happened in a canon book and at no point does the sourcebook retcon it.
You still said the Thanos Sourcebook should cover a non canon event. The book covers his adventures. Believe whatever you want. I am right.

Again, The Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight happened in a canon book and at no point does the sourcebook retcon it. which means that it's still canon.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Again, The Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight happened in a canon book and at no point does the sourcebook retcon it. which means that it's still canon.
That's not canon to the real Thanos ala the Sourcebook. That's my opinion which is logical.

At no point does the sourcebook say that the canon Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight isn't canon to the "real Thanos".

Originally posted by Silent Master
At no point does the sourcebook say that the canon Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight isn't canon to the "real Thanos".
Why would they cover a noncanon showing ?

As the sourcebook doesn't retcon the SG/Thanos fight, You have provided no proof that the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight isn't canon.

Originally posted by Silent Master
As the sourcebook doesn't retcon the SG/Thanos fight, You have provided no proof that the Squirrel Girl/Thanos fight isn't canon.
The fight was never canon anyway. There doesn't need to be a retcon imo.