ROTS Kenobi vs. Zone Anakin

Started by mnat80127 pages

Originally posted by Intrepid37
Anakin stomps in seconds.
Don't troll Anakin fanboy

Said the troll? lulwut?

lolol

Originally posted by mnat801
My point being Kenobi wasn't able to show if he had improved since AOTC like Anakin did.

That being the case I highly doubt that Obi went from "disappointing" Dooku from AOTC to the case of obliterating him as Anakin did.

Originally posted by Based
That being the case I highly doubt that Obi went from "disappointing" Dooku from AOTC to the case of obliterating him as Anakin did.

That would be literally impossible, considering how Fisto, while holding back, was a superior swordsman to AotC Kenobi.

Originally posted by mnat801
Agreed, I just mean how Dooku went to the full depths of trying to get rid of Kenobi by not only force pushing him 2 times within the first seconds of the fight, but also throwing a huge deck on him so he could not move.

My point being Kenobi wasn't able to show if he had improved since AOTC like Anakin did.

I don't get it. He was in a sword fight against Dooku, and he had help. How did he not get a chance to prove himself?

Oh and welcome back.

Originally posted by Intrepid37
That would be literally impossible, considering how Fisto, while holding back, was a superior swordsman to AotC Kenobi.

He went from being below Fisto, to being above peak Ventress. That is a big difference.

Originally posted by Based
That being the case I highly doubt that Obi went from "disappointing" Dooku from AOTC to the case of obliterating him as Anakin did.
Whether you doubt it or not is irrelevant as we never saw it happen. Shouldn't make assumptions to prove your point.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
I don't get it. He was in a sword fight against Dooku, and he had help. How did he not get a chance to prove himself?

Oh and welcome back.

I don't know how to make my point more clearer so I'll just leave it.

Thanks for the friendly welcome.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
Said the troll? lulwut?
So Anakin stomps Kenobi in seconds, yet a conversion to the dark side and Kenobi is able to disassemble him without even killing him? Come again please.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
He went from being below Fisto, to being above peak Ventress. That is a big difference.

So what? Being above ''peak Ventress'' is a far cry off being above Anakin-'I can outduel Dooku in 30 seconds''.

Originally posted by Intrepid37
So what? Being above ''peak Ventress'' is a far cry off being above Anakin-'I can outduel Dooku in 30 seconds''.

Not comparing him to Skywalker. Just pointing out there is a big difference between AOTC Kenobi and ROTS Kenobi.

I know that.

Originally posted by Intrepid37
I know that.

Anakin kills him in seconds.. LMAO what a joke. Kenobi still wins... it will just take alittle longer

kenobi

Kenobi would only win if Anakin made a stupid mistake. Which going to by the movie Zone Anakin would not make.

How does Kenobi win against someone who killed Dooku in 20 seconds?

You claim kenobi only won because of circumstances against maul and Savage... was based on Focus and going offensive... yet you leave out Anakin only beating dooku because Dooku underestimated Anakin... depleted force reserves when fighting off Kenobi and Anakin at the same time. Those are key reasons why Dooku lost.

It's true Dooku had depleted reserves by that point, but he depleted them by fighting Skywalker, not Kenobi. After he Force-hucked Kenobi against a wall, Anakin was "all over him", as Dooku "spent lavishly of his reserve of the Force merely to meet these attacks without being cut in half, and Skywalker-- Skywalker was getting stronger."

And that's not Zone Anakin. Up until then Dooku had been arrogant, then shocked at their sudden change of technique. But nowhere is it said they were tiring him down. And once it does say he started getting tired, his fatigue is being attributed solely to Anakin. Not Zone Anakin, just regular old jerk Anakin. Jerkakin. Dooku, even with "depleted Force reserves" still took down Kenobi. That's how strong the old man was. And Zonakin utterly snaps his shit up. How is regular ol' Obi-Wan "beaten by a weakened Dooku" going to stand against Anakin "The Guy Who Actually Weakens Dooku" Skywalker... when he's even more powerful than his TGWAWD self?

Kenobi beats anakin again by virtue of knowing him better than anyone else. His victory on Mustafar wasn't an accident. Matchup problem for Anakin. in a round robin tournament, i'm sure Zone anakin wins a lot more than ROTS kenobi, but in THIS fight, kenobi wins.

Kenobi was hard-pressed against a raving very conflicted Anakin and only won due to some ridiculous writing.

Against a more powerful "clear-headed" Anakin, Kenobi has no chance.

Ankain wins this every time.