Thanos with the Infinity Gauntlet vs Dawn of Time Anti-Monitor...

Started by TheGodKiller27 pages

Originally posted by zopzop
Logical paradox. How can an omnipotent/omniscient being (Doom with the IG) create something MORE powerful than himself?

Hickman.......... 😘


IIRC, those creatures were never stated to be more powerful than the IG.

Anyways, this isn't the first time the "nigh-omnipotent beings get overwhelmed by their own creations" trope has been played out in comics. Mangog in first appearance, clearly appeared to be too much for Odin and we have a recent example with the Celestials and the Exterminators.

^^^ If they weren't more powerful than the IG,
then what's the plot behind the lost? Or is it good ol' PIS?

Originally posted by TheGodKiller

^The original Nazi-Reed was unable to defeat the heroes of his
native universe without going batshit insane and blowing up his whole universe.

And when Doom reclaimed this Reed's IG and went back to his
universe to reignite it, he created a large collection of science/magic
hybrid monsters who eventually managed to overwhelm him in a
straight-up fight, even while he wielded the IG.

So no, the IG, for all the power it grants in its native universe, is still
with limits and operates within universal constraints.


I disagree good friend.
It's in the IG's history to necessitate time to adapt to the abilities it grants.

I find it funny, how exploding an entire universe,
then re-creating said entire universe is nowadays a walk in the park.
Cap (another noob) pushed back/away that other on-coming entire universe.

Anyway, that seemingly Doom plot you brought up is exactly that, a "plot."
If he created "monsters" with the IG and then got overwhelmed by them,
then I'm not doubting the IG cause of it,
since the IG made reality that way for him.

Lastly, I'd like to read that myself, so my opinion, is just that for now.

Originally posted by Mr Master
^^^ If they weren't more powerful than the IG,
then what's the plot behind the lost? Or is it good ol' PIS?

That the wielder of such power is always fallible. Even a god can be defeated. Even omnipotence has its limits(at least from a comic book perspective). You know, the usual tripe.
Originally posted by Mr Master

I disagree good friend.
It's in the IG's history to necessitate time to adapt to the abilities it grants.

I find it funny, how exploding an entire universe,
then re-creating said entire universe is nowadays a walk in the park.
Cap (another noob) pushed back/away that other on-coming entire universe.

Anyway, that seemingly Doom plot you brought up is exactly that, a "plot."
If he created "monsters" with the IG and then got overwhelmed by them,
then I'm not doubting the IG cause of it,
since the IG made reality that way for him.

Lastly, I'd like to read that myself, so my opinion, is just that for now.


The Reed was engaged in a shadow war against the heroes of his Earth, for years iirc. And he supposedly started this war after he acquired the "God Hand" ala the OG.

Doom had the IG all throughout the reignited Creation of that universe. The initial phases of the Big Bang can last several thousand years. So he had more than enough time to get accustomed to his IG. Get decent enough experience with it. Not to mention that this is Doom we're talking about, who's successfully usurped vast power-sources before, so he should already considerable experience with that kind of thing.

Fantastic Four 605.1 and Fantastic Four 611. The former has the Nazi-Reed scenes, and the latter has the Doom scenes.

Originally posted by TheGodKiller
^The original Nazi-Reed was unable to defeat the heroes of his native universe without going batshit insane and blowing up his whole universe.

And when Doom reclaimed this Reed's IG and went back to his universe to reignite it, he created a large collection of science/magic hybrid monsters who eventually managed to overwhelm him in a straight-up fight, even while he wielded the IG.

So no, the IG, for all the power it grants in its native universe, is still with limits and operates within universal constraints.

👆

Originally posted by TheGodKiller
Doom had the IG all throughout the reignited Creation of that universe. The initial phases of the Big Bang can last several thousand years. So he had more than enough time to get accustomed to his IG. Get decent enough experience with it.
Everything Doom did in that universe took him six days. On the seventh day, the universe rebelled against him.

Originally posted by ODG
Everything Doom did in that universe took him six days. On the seventh day, the universe rebelled against him.

Depends whether one wants to read Hickman's biblical references in a literal manner, or an allegorical manner. Personally, I read it the latter way.

However, even if my interpretation of the timeline of the feat is incorrect, Doom still had 7 days to master the IG, and it would be unreasonable to assume he'd be unable to do so, as Doom is used to mastering and achieving proficiency with omnipotent power sources in short spans of time.

anti monitor at the dawn of time was multi-universal, still, he isn't defeating IG thanos.

AM wins.

Originally posted by TheGodKiller

Depends whether one wants to read Hickman's biblical references
in a literal manner, or an allegorical manner. Personally, I read it the
latter way.

However, even if my interpretation of the timeline of the feat is
incorrect, Doom still had 7 days to master the IG, and it would be
unreasonable to assume he'd be unable to do so, as Doom is used to
mastering and achieving proficiency with omnipotent power sources in
short spans of time.


Imo, it's too much of a coincidence so I'm leaning towards ODG's perspective,
which I'm assuming suggests Hickman made the context of that
story in a familiar light to the "God" creation scenario of the Bible.

Evidently, Hickman views the IG as God-like power.
Hickman also told Galan that the IG makes you "All Powerful"
(withIN its respective universe)
So,
I can't wait to find the plot behind Doom losing to anything withIN said reality.
(I'm reading the relevant issues plus priors and soon followups)

Also, unless there's clear evidence Doom "mastered" the IG.
there's no true reason to believe he did. Especially if he found
limitations withIN a universe where he is supposed to be GOD!
(that ... or PIS)

I don't think Doom's Science/Magic children 'beating' him has anything to do with them being more powerful than the IG. I believe Doom lost because he wanted to lose.

As Doom himself said at the end of the issue: "I was a God, Valeria. I found it... Beneath me."

Doom sampled Godhood, and was left unimpressed. T'was a position unbefitting of his greatness.

Originally posted by Mr Master
Imo, it's too much of a coincidence so I'm leaning towards ODG's perspective,
which I'm assuming suggests Hickman made the context of that
story in a familiar light to the "God" creation scenario of the Bible.

Evidently, Hickman views the IG as God-like power.
Hickman also told Galan that the IG makes you "All Powerful"
(withIN its respective universe)
So,
I can't wait to find the plot behind Doom losing to anything withIN said reality.
(I'm reading the relevant issues plus priors and soon followups)

Also, unless there's clear evidence Doom "mastered" the IG.
there's no true reason to believe he did. Especially if he found
limitations withIN a universe where he is supposed to be GOD!
(that ... or PIS)


You're only focusing on the "IG makes you GOD in its native universe" statement by Hickman, even while ignoring the blatant limitations that Hickman has demonstrated his IGs to have.

Hickman also told us on-panel(via adult Franklin) that kid Franklin was "God" in his created universe. Here's the scan where this statement is made:

That's not proof though that Franklin's actually omnipotent, or that he can't face constraints in his reality.

The IG is limited to a universal scale and scope within its native reality. It maybe described as being all-powerful in its universe, but that by no means implies it to be unbeatable, or that a multiversal scale omnipotent power-source can't exceed it.

On a sidenote, in one of Hickman's FF(future foundation) issues, an alternate UN erased an alternate IG. So there, IG vs UN is a tied 1-1 score. 😛

Originally posted by Galan007
I don't think Doom's Science/Magic children 'beating' him has anything to do with them being more powerful than the IG. I believe Doom lost because he wanted to lose.

As Doom himself said at the end of the issue: "I was a God, Valeria. I found it... Beneath me."

Doom sampled Godhood, and was left unimpressed. T'was a position unbefitting of his greatness.


Speculation. Doom probably lost because he was unimpressed by the IG and subconsciously "willed" the IG to make his children beat him(the idea of which comes from an arrogance-loaded statement from Doom himself). Or the IG acted on his innermost insecurities and manifested them in the form of deefat at the hands of his creations.

Whatever the case, the IG is very clearly shown to be limited to being universal in terms of both scale and scope of its power. Or do you think that beings with legit multiversal omnipotents like Lucifer or Mxy would fall before an IG in caid IG's universe?

On another sidenote, at this point I can confidently say that if we had a Voltron-merge of a billion Celestials, then said entity could one-shot the IG with the very same ease that a 4-Celestial Voltron one-shotted an amped Galactus.

I think that the "Celestials are aspects of a single multiversal entity" statement from Pak's X-Termination run might hint towards such an entity. I recall a poster called Magnon theorizing this very same thing regarding the Voltron-Celestial long before Pak started writing those X-books. Yet another sign(to me), that Marvel writers frequent comic book battleboards, and plagiarize ideas/theories of fans/posters on such battleboards.

^^ Either way, it's the IG defeating itself via Doom "subconsciously"
or "willingly" due to Galan's reasoning.

Lucifer & Mxy have nothing to do with Marvel.

In Marvel, the IG makes you "All Powerful" withIN its universe.
Therefore, nothing defeats it withIN said universe ... in Marvel.

Again, why cross-company battles on this level don't work imo.

Celestials or the supposed "multiversal one" get stomped by the IG in its native reality.

Originally posted by Galan007

I don't think Doom's Science/Magic children 'beating' him has
anything to do with them being more powerful than the IG. I believe
Doom lost because he wanted to lose.

As Doom himself said at the end of the issue:

"I was a God, Valeria. I found it... Beneath me."

Doom sampled Godhood, and was left unimpressed.
T'was a position unbefitting of his greatness.


I knew it. 👆 That makes more sense. It's not "pis" ... it's "plot."

^

Originally posted by TheGodKiller
IIRC, those creatures were never stated to be more powerful than the IG.

Anyways, this isn't the first time the "nigh-omnipotent beings get overwhelmed by their own creations" trope has been played out in comics. Mangog in first appearance, clearly appeared to be too much for Odin and we have a recent example with the Celestials and the Exterminators.

^ 😐

Originally posted by TheGodKiller

On a sidenote, in one of Hickman's FF(future foundation) issues, an
alternate UN erased an alternate IG. So there

Scans of that happening to the wielder in the IG's native universe.

Originally posted by Mr Master
^^ Either way, it's the IG defeating itself via Doom "subconsciously"
or "willingly" due to Galan's reasoning.

Lucifer & Mxy have nothing to do with Marvel.

In Marvel, the IG makes you "All Powerful" withIN its universe.
Therefore, nothing defeats it withIN said universe ... in Marvel.

Again, why cross-company battles on this level don't work imo.


Which shows us that there are limits to its power.

How convenient. Dismissing omnipotent characters from other companies with the "[insert_random_omnipoten_character] has nothing to do with Marvel". You do realize that hickman making his IGs non-functional outside their universe is a concept borrowed from a Marvel/DC crossover, don't you?

Except for another universe that pushed against the 616-Ig, and broke 5 gems while causing the 6th to disappear. Or Nazi-Reed failing to defeat a horde of Earth heroes without going batshit insane and blowing up his universe.

Then stop debating on the VS forums. 90% of the threads involve cross-company battles, including those in which omnipotent or all-powerful type characters are involved. Hell, this thread itself is a cross-company battle. Yet you take the time to respond to it. I wonder why?

Originally posted by Mr Master
Scans of that happening to the wielder in the IG's native universe.

Happened outside, in the Bridge. It was the same blast though, that failed to erase alternate Eson in that issue.

Originally posted by Mr Master
^ 😐

That's me saying the same thing as Galan. AKA, "Doom's creations were not powerful than his IG".

Originally posted by TheGodKiller
On a sidenote, in one of Hickman's FF(future foundation) issues, an alternate UN erased an alternate IG. So there, IG vs UN is a tied 1-1 score. 😛
Not sure if serious..? But that IG was completely powerless/worthless at the time because it was not within its native universe. The UN destroying a powerless IG is no more impressive than nullifying the Crown Jewels.

Originally posted by TheGodKiller
Speculation.
Yes, it is speculation-- hence the careful choice of verbiage in my previous post. However, it is very logical speculation based on what we know to be fact. Doom didn't enjoy being God-- he isn't going to stay in a position he despises just for the lulz.

Originally posted by Mr Master
I knew it. 👆 That makes more sense. It's not "pis" ... it's "plot."
In the end, only Doom can beat Doom. 👆

Originally posted by Galan007
That IG was completely powerless/worthless at the time because it was not within its native universe. The UN destroying a powerless IG is no more impressive than if it were used to nullify the crown jewels.

IG vs UN score on panel is still 1-1. 😉
Originally posted by Galan007

Yes, it is speculation-- hence the careful choice of verbiage in my previous post. However, it is very logical speculation based on what we know to be fact. Doom didn't enjoy being God. He isn't going to stay in a position he despises just for the lulz-- he's going to find a way out of it.

He would have to devise such a measure before the creatures rebelled against him. On-panel though, we saw his misery begin only when he had already been overwhelmed.
Originally posted by Galan007
In the end, only Doom can beat Doom. 👆

True that. Unfortunately, the IG is not Doom.

Originally posted by Galan007
Not sure if serious..?

Not sure if incapable of comprehending the purpose pf posting a smilie..?