Indeed, SWL seems to not realize that not wanting to count them doesn't make them not count, especially when there are citations and examples that directly contract his made-up conclusions.
I like how his logic is, "The Matukai are called Whirlwinds. The Jedi are called Whirlwinds. The Matukai are clearly better because ????".
Also, one of the Emperor's Hands I talked about? Arden Lyn?
She was attacked by three high-level Inquisitors. She killed one and wounded another, due to her skills in the martial art Teräs Käsi.
Multiple Jedi including Bultar swan know that art, and Arden Lyn's been defeated by Jedi on multiple occasions, both during the First Schism, and she failed an attempt on the not-yet-master Luke.
Pwned
Do NOT use wookieepedia.
Heck, let him use Wookieepedia! He keeps on saying 'look at wookieepedia,' but if you look at it, the quotes do not say what he claims them to say.
Consider how sad it is that he insists that he gets his information from there and yet cannot actually manage to find and cut-and-past quotes from it that don't need to be massively exaggerated in order to get close to his conclusions/
Star Wars LogicThe Matukai who joined Luke Skywalker's jedi praxeum were Matukai Apprentices, Matukai who just begun their training in the Matukai philosophy.
Nope, nothing says that. Baseless assumption 1.
You should've listened to Frozoner while you had the chance and ignore me. But now lets bring the actuality in differentiation between Jedi and Matukai.The Jedi have never reached the Strength and Body Maneuverability of a whirlwind, the Matukai have.
Nope, directly contradicted. Lie 1.
The Jedi have never developed a technique that immediately refreshes your spirit, giving feats of strength and power exceeding what the body was originally capable of, thus becoming stronger then what the body once was before being fatigued, the Matukai Done this.
Nope, Jedi have shown great feats of strength and power exceeding what the body was originally capable of on many cited occasions. Lie 2.
The Jedi have never developed a physically immunity to all poisons & illnesses, the Matukai have. The Jedi reached the body level to being resistant to poisons, not being immune to them.
Ding-ding! Finally, one thing accurate. Actually I'm not sure if Jedi have never done so, but poison immunity is definitely something they have going for them.
The Jedi have never reached the speed of a helicopter propeller with their Melee weapons, being viewed as a virtual whirlwind of Metal and blades, the Matukai have.
This is just repeating lie 1, which makes it lie 3.
The Jedi had the Lightsaber style known as Jar-kar. That Lightsaber style was known as a brilliant whirlwind. The brilliant lightsaber whirlwind brilliant Jar-Kar has been defined as an almost vertical column of rapidly swung lightsabers, not reaching the speed of a actual whirlwind (Virtual Whirlwind) but something of similarity (Briliant whirlwind)
Number of things that say the Matukai one is faster: Zero. In fact, the only description is the word 'whirlwind' and, like you say, 'virtual whirlwind' is the term used, not actual!
There is precisely squat that differentiates the two.
Lie 4.
To put it simple, the inquisitorius were the organization that assassinated the Matukai adepts.
And Jedi and Arden Lyn, yet Jedi like Kyle Katarn were able to fight them off, and Arden Lyn was able to do well against their best, yet the Matukai were unable to do similarly or escape.
Both Yuuzhan Vong and their supporters killed several Matukai apprentices. Experienced Matukai Adepts were gone at that time, and the lesser experienced adepts were gone at that time.
Nope, the last masters would've had plenty of time to train new Matukai up to full by then. This was decades after the purges ended, and there were Matukai with full training who survived to pass it on.
Lie 5.
I never said the Matukai were the first, but ONE of the first force orders that suffered. the Matukai adepts were largely caught off guard, being assassinated in the process.
So they just large somehow didn't notice the Jedi being attacked before them? The Imperial Inquisition that took them down didn't even *exist* back when the purges started, meaning they had some warning, at least months like I said.
And again, they operated in pairs and trios, and nor were they lacking in finely honed conventional senses to warn them. It beggers belief that in those cases at least one of them wouldn't be able to put up a fight.
Once again the RPG hero's guide was where the Zeison Sha & Matukai were first brought into canon, in Star Wars time thats 4,000 BBY. Using the 1st Generation Matukai Adept prestige tradition in comparison to Imperial inquisitors, is pathetic. Same goes for trying to Base the first generation Zeison Sha in comparison to other orders.
The Hero's Guide covers a variety of time, from 4,000 BBY to the Clone Wars, and primarily the Clone Wars at that. The early stuff is mostly mentioned as history, and presents the Matukai as they were during the Clone Wars. The idea that it's only ancient stuff is unfounded like you've been told, and that's lie 6.
And they were also in the Jedi Training Manual, which goes all the way up to 30-40ABY.
So you'd still be wrong.
Common Sense would have told you the Zeison Sha are the most powerful Light Side order. Since they are stronger then most, or even all when it comes to Mind Prowers & Prowess. The Mind is what controls it all. It controls The Physical and spiritual manifestation.
Common sense says nothing says they're the most powerful, and it also says that the book specifically notes they avoided the Empire's hunter as protection rather than hunting.
Also, they were not noted as being the strongest in the mind, or even using mind powers at all. They were strong in TK, but a group like the Baran Do Sages puts much more focus on the mind, as do the Jedi. Baseless Assumption 2.
Common Sense would have told you the Matukai are the 2nd most powerful Light Side Order.
The ones wiped out by a group the Jedi wiped out? And with nothing saying they're all that powerful either, and specifically noted to recruit from people with lowish force connections? Lie 7 and baseless assumption 3.
Do you need the Copy & pasted quotes on the Matukai's physical superiority, and Zeison Sha's unmatched telekinetic Might to Destroy even more of your arguments then what has already been trashed ?
Considering you've failed to post any and your arguments have been packs of lies and assumptions that get continuously get shot down, yes, that'd be nice.
I'll pre-emptively note that quotes only say the Matukai have high physical training and the Zeison Sha are very powerful in TK, and do not, of course, say they are overall better in any way, shape, or form. It means they're good in their respective areas, that's it, and it doesn't mean others can't also be good in those same areas.
Using the description 'whirlwind' does not mean that their whirlwinds are better than the Jedi ability with the description 'whirlwind,' and so on.
As, btw, I have specifically noted that the Jedi Path book says the Matukai are only among the best martial artists, and the ZS's telekinetics are only mentioned as being better than many Jedi but not Jedi who themselves specialize in TK.
That's pre-emptive baseless assumptions 4 and 5.