Can the Sword of Gryffindor destroy Sauron's ring ?

Originally posted by FrothByte
Both Aragorn and Gandalf were afraid to hold the ring for any length of time, simply because they new they couldn't resist it's pull. Only the Bagginses were pure of heart enough to endure prolonged exposure to the ring. I'd definitely say that the ring's corruption powers are greater than the horcruxes.

Who is to say whether the one ring could even corrupt someone from another world since specific magic was created to rule Middle Earth.

For within these rings was bound the strength and will to govern each race.

Sauron forged a master ring to dominate these specific rings which only pertain to Middle Earth.

Horcruxes corrupt anyone who wears them and isn't tied into specific magic overpowering these other rings which only deals with Middle Earth.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Nice attempt to shift the burden, however you still haven't provided any proof that basilisk venom would destroy the ring.

What horcrux resistance feats are you talking about?

Originally posted by Silent Master
What horcrux resistance feats are you talking about?

IOW, you have no feats.

Originally posted by Silent Master
IOW, you have no feats.

Like I said, you have no feats.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Like I said, you have no feats.

Like I said, you have no feats.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Like I said, you have no feats.

If you had any feats, you would have posted them by now, as it is you're just doing your usual song & dance.

For someone who doubted that Fiendfyre destroyed a horcrux [quanchi] this is for you : Movie 8, the diadem hidden in the Room of Requirement, Goyle casts Fiendfyre [which ends up killing himself and Crabbe] and the Fiendfyre destroys the diadem.

Now for what actually happened in the last part of movie eight - The Sword of Gryffindor WAS NOT in the Room of Requirement. In fact, Harry lost it when the trio and the Goblin invaded Bellatrix's vault to get Hufflepuff's cup. Ron and Hermione went down to the Chamber of Secrets to gather Basilisk Venom [to be used to destroy the Cup. The Sword didn't come back to Hogwarts until Neville pulled it out of the Sorting Hat and chopped off Nagini's head. Therefore, it was not embedded with Fiendfyre, which seems to be the only thing that might be able to compete with Mount Doom's lava.

And so we go back to Scarlet Fox's tentative solution - IF the Sword can be embedded with MD's lava, then it would be able to destroy the One Ring. As the ring must be destroyed with MD's lava - LotR is certain on that much. [I haven't seen "The Hobbit, is it mentioned in that movie?]

Originally posted by siriuswriter
For someone who doubted that Fiendfyre destroyed a horcrux [quanchi] this is for you : Movie 8, the diadem hidden in the Room of Requirement, Goyle casts Fiendfyre [which ends up killing himself and Crabbe] and the Fiendfyre destroys the diadem.

Now for what actually happened in the last part of movie eight - The Sword of Gryffindor WAS NOT in the Room of Requirement. In fact, Harry lost it when the trio and the Goblin invaded Bellatrix's vault to get Hufflepuff's cup. Ron and Hermione went down to the Chamber of Secrets to gather Basilisk Venom [to be used to destroy the Cup. The Sword didn't come back to Hogwarts until Neville pulled it out of the Sorting Hat and chopped off Nagini's head. Therefore, it was not embedded with Fiendfyre, which seems to be the only thing that might be able to compete with Mount Doom's lava.

And so we go back to Scarlet Fox's tentative solution - IF the Sword can be embedded with MD's lava, then it would be able to destroy the One Ring. As the ring must be destroyed with MD's lava - LotR is certain on that much. [I haven't seen "The Hobbit, is it mentioned in that movie?]

Originally posted by Silent Master
If you had any feats, you would have posted them by now, as it is you're just doing your usual song & dance.

Like I said, If you had any feats, you would have posted them by now, as it is you're just doing your usual song & dance.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Like I said, If you had any feats, you would have posted them by now, as it is you're just doing your usual song & dance.

Originally posted by quanchi112
This is only due to specific magic over the other rings which only pertains to Middle Earth not any other fictional universe.

Who is to say whether the one ring could even corrupt someone from another world since specific magic was created to rule Middle Earth.

For within these rings was bound the strength and will to govern each race.

Sauron forged a master ring to dominate these specific rings which only pertain to Middle Earth.

Horcruxes corrupt anyone who wears them and isn't tied into specific magic overpowering these other rings which only deals with Middle Earth.

The ring was made to corrupt the creatures of middle earth, and one of the easiest to corrupt were humans. Harry Potter and co. are humans. Now if Doby were the one wielding the sword, that might be different.

This thread is about whether or not the sword can destroy the ring, that means the burden is on those backing the sword. If the thread was about whether or not the ring could withstand the sword, then the burden would be on those backing the ring.

If you don’t like it, Blame the person who started the thread.

Originally posted by FrothByte
The ring was made to corrupt the creatures of middle earth, and one of the easiest to corrupt were humans. Harry Potter and co. are humans. Now if Doby were the one wielding the sword, that might be different.

I'm just finally dispelling these myths once and for all.

Originally posted by Silent Master
This thread is about whether or not the sword can destroy the ring, that means the burden is on those backing the sword. If the thread was about whether or not the ring could withstand the sword, then the burden would be on those backing the ring.

If you don’t like it, Blame the person who started the thread.