Khan vs. Darth Vader (pre suit)

Started by quanchi11288 pages

Originally posted by Robtard
Clearly says George Lucas > all others. This is from your own source.

Don't you mean Chee? 😂 And that 'all statements from George Lucas' part is from Chee; under the Holocron section, the same part you sourced from. So clearly, Chee > you too.

Sold the rights and the man whose job it is with regards to continuity says t canon not g canon.

iPad. Categorizes them perfectly. Also quoted creator. Let it go.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Sold the rights and the man whose job it is with regards to continuity says t canon not g canon.

iPad. Categorizes them perfectly. Also quoted creator. Let it go.

And Chee says George Lucas' statements are canon.

😂 "iPad did it!" again. George Lucas > all people in regards to SW. Accept and move on.

Originally posted by Robtard
And Chee says George Lucas' statements are canon.

😂 "iPad did it!" again. George Lucas > all people in regards to SW. Accept and move on.

Lucas sold the rights. Disney owns Star Wars. T canon. Right in article.

Khan wins.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Yes, and that clearly says the series is t canon. Thanks for proving me right. I also cited creator of Star Wars Clone Wars movie.

Not arguable. Your tattling made sure of that. Continuity buff and Lucas sold his rights.

😂

Khan wins and quit harping on being wrong. I expect it from you.

The series and the cgi movie are two different things. Stop talking about them like they are the same.

And I didn't see "t canon" anywhere in his post. Point it out for me?

You ***s still talking about the canon BS? My Lucas quote put an end to it and Impediment's ruling solidified how it will be treated in the MvF. Move on. Circular discussions are stupid.

Originally posted by dadudemon
You ***s still talking about the canon BS? My Lucas quote put an end to it and Impediment's ruling solidified how it will be treated in the MvF. Move on. Circular discussions are stupid.

its not a "circular discussion". its quanchi repeating the same lie over and over.

Originally posted by dadudemon
You ***s still talking about the canon BS? My Lucas quote put an end to it and Impediment's ruling solidified how it will be treated in the MvF. Move on. Circular discussions are stupid.

I guess we were just trying to defend the ruling because Quan still seemed to think his word was above everyone else's. you're right, the ruling was final and that should have been that. It's been ruled, it's legal, it's law, we all know it, and we are done. It is canon.

Originally posted by dadudemon
You ***s still talking about the canon BS? My Lucas quote put an end to it and Impediment's ruling solidified how it will be treated in the MvF. Move on. Circular discussions are stupid.

quan doesn't think he has to listen to mods.

Soooo uuuuuh. Anyone see Quan requested to close out the ole' Battlezone?

Wonder what that's all about?

😖hifty:

Indeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeed.
Its quite the mystery.
😖hifty:

/snicker

creepsmile

Be careful, or he might beg ask a mod to lock this thread as well

What a horrific tragedy that would be. Don't do it Quan!!

😖hifty:

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
What a horrific tragedy that would be. Don't do it Quan!!

😖hifty:

I liked this thread. I learned some stuff about both the characters and franchises. Maybe that learning only occurred once every 80-120 posts, but it happened. 🙂

i learned that khan is very sexy and has that "zazz" factor that anakin lacks. too bad manikin skywalker kills him 🙁

Originally posted by quanchi112
Lucas sold the rights. Disney owns Star Wars. T canon. Right in article.

Khan wins.

Article still say George Lucas' statements are canon. Stop being so childish already.

Nope, as shown.

Originally posted by dadudemon
You ***s still talking about the canon BS? My Lucas quote put an end to it and Impediment's ruling solidified how it will be treated in the MvF. Move on. Circular discussions are stupid.

His new angle is that George Lucas' words don't matter anymore, despite previously trying to use a lie that George Lucas said the 2008 film wasn't canon somewhere.

This is on top of citing wookieepedia, which says George Lucas' statements are canon.

This post needs to be addressed (modified after getting some sense talked into me by Sadako):

Originally posted by dadudemon
Quanchi, talk to me for a bit.

Why does Khan win?

Vader has shown speed that exceeds any speed or reaction feats from Khan.

Khan wins the durability department.

Anakin wins the text-book brains department (he was as smart as if not smarter than Khan, when it came to engineering, as an 8 year old boy, than Khan) but Khan wins the deception intelligence contest.

Vader wins in strength by a significant margin based on feats but both are low-end super human.

Vader wins simply because Khan has no way to contend with Vader's speed, precog, and lightsaber. I won't go down the path and claim Vader's saber can block that big gun: I don't believe it does. But I do think Vader is more than fast enough to move clear due to both his speed and battle precog. Vader quickly closes the gap between Khan, dodging his gun firing and blocking the small stuff, and chops up Khan once he gets close enough.

If it goes H2H, I think Khan wins. I think I have been as objective as possible about this discussion.

So convince me that Vader's speed and precog is not enough to contend with Khan (without using low-end speed and precog feats from Vader). If you can do that, then I will support your position.

im just glad you're learning stuff about star wars, ddm. soon you'll be all set for ep7.

did you see ESB yet? 🙂