The Official Tier List of Comic Book Ranks For Non-Comic Characters

Metahuman

High

Angron (1), Castiel (1), Dante (DMC1&4) (2), Dante (DMC2) (3), Doomsday (DCAU) (1), Guyver (1), Hideyoshi Toyotomi (Sengoku Basara) (2), Ichigo (1), Invincible (1), Kenshiro (3), Kojuro Katakura (Sengoku Basara) (1), Kratos (God of War) (1), Lemen Russ (1), Lorgar (1), Luffy (1), Luke Skywalker (2), Masamune Date (Sengoku Basara) (2), Master Asia (3), Megaman X (2), Mew (1), Naruto (1), Comic!Rainbow Dash (1), Raoh (2), Riku (Kingdom Hearts (2), Saitama (1), Sanguinius (1), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (1), Sora (2), Tetsuo Shima (Akira) (3), Yukimura Sanada (Sengoku Basara) (2) Zero (2), Zero Superman (DCAU) (1),

Mid

Alex Mercer (4), Alita (Battle Angel Alita/Last Order) (1), Alucard (Hellsing) (3), Ben Tennyson (Composite) (1), Blade Liger (1), Captain Planet (1), Cloverfield Monster (1), Evil!Cole McGrath (InFamous) (4), Dante (DmC) (2), Death (Darksiders) (3), Donkey Kong (2), Fingolfin (1), Flame Princess (1), Hancock (1), Hayato Furinji (HSD) (2), Ice King (1), Jackie Chan (Talismans) (1), Jin Kazama (1), Kaiju's (PR) (1), Kain the Vampire (3), Ken (Street Fighter) (2), Kirby (3), Kharn The Betrayer (1), Knuckles (2), Kojuro Katakura (Sengoku Basara) (1), Liger Zero (1), Link, Hero of Legend (6), Link, Hero of Light (6), Link, Hero of Time (6), Link, Hero of Winds (6), Mario (2), Mega Man (4), Megaman X (2), Merry Dreameater (1), Natsu (Fairy Tail) (1), Optimus Prime (1), Pride (1),Cyborg!Raiden (MGS) (1), Rainbow Dash (1), Raziel (3), Ryu (Street Fighter) (2), Samurai Jack (4), Samus Aran (2), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (2), Scourge The Hedgehog (2), Seras (Hellsing) (1), Silver the Hedgehog (2), Shadow (2), Sonic (2), Sora (Kingdom Hearts) (1), Titus, Second Captain of the Ultramarines (4), Twilight Sparkle (1), Vergil (DmC) (2), Yoh Asakura (1)

Low

Aang (Avatar) (2), Albert Wesker (Resident Evil Games) (6), Andrew Detmer (2), Big MacIntosh (1), Billith (1), Good!Cole McGrath (3), Cloud (FF7) (2), Commander Shepherd (4), Corvo Attano (1), Eddie Riggs (2), Edward (Twilight) (1), Envy (1), Eren Jager (Attack on Titan) (1), Fluttershy (1), Gluttony (1), Greed (1), Guts (Berserk) (1), Haseo (DotHack) (1), Hellboy (1), Jack (Mass Effect) (2), Jak (1), Kain the Vampire (2), Kenichi (2), Lelith Hesperax (1), Lu Bu (3), Lust (1), Master Chief (Halo) (9), Metabee (1), Pride (1), Ratchet (3), Raziel (2), Russell Edgington (2), Ryu Hayabusa (1), Samara (Mass Effect) (2), Sam Gideon (ARS) (2), Shining Armour (1), Shizuo Heiwajima (Durarara) (2), Sloth (1), Sylar (2), Thorkell (Vinland Saga) (1), Voldemort (1), War (Darksiders) (3), Warlow (True Blood) (2), Wrath (1)

Street

High

Adam Jensen (1), Afro Samurai (2), AppleJack (1), Brock Samson (2), Chris Redfield (3), Dexter (Dexter's Laboratory) (1), Edward Elric (2), Finn the Human (2), Fluttershy (2), Geralt of Rivia (The Witcher) (2), Isaac Clark (1), Jackie Chan (JCA) (1), Kazuma Kiryu (2), Marth (2), Miyamoto Musashi (Vagabond) (1), Pinkie (1), The Prince (Sands of Time) (3), Rarity (1), Solid Snake (2), Riddick (2), Voldemort (2)

Mid

Achilles (Troy) (3), Aragorn (4), Captain Falcon (2), Falco Lombardi (2), Fox McCloud (2), Gregor Clegane (3), Jackie Chan (2), James Bond (2), Joanna Dark (1), John Marston (2), Krystal the Fox (1), Marcus Fenix (4), Undertaker (2), Wolf O'Donnell (2), Xin (Kingdom) (2)

Low

Ash Williams (1), Fluttershy (1), Huey Freeman (2), Nathan Drake (2), Riley Freeman (2), Roger Smith (Big O) (1), Sly Cooper (2), Stewie Griffin (3), Turanga Leela (2)

Now in two pieces because character limit.

This should be up to date, let me know if I missed anything.

Kratos for low Herald

Magnus the Red for mid herald.

Magnus is good and all. But he is outclassed by all the high heralds and several of the mid heralds.

Originally posted by Charlotte DeBel
There were some ambiguous feats, basically the debate for allowing Luke in this was based on "can Luke replicate Starkiller's Star Destroyer feat or no".
Based on some EU absurdity I'm OK with him being a low herald.

Luke can easily replicate any of Starkiller's feats.

Luke Skywalker for LH then.

Originally posted by BloodRain
Luke Skywalker for LH then.

Both aang and war for mid metahuman

Originally posted by ares834
Kratos for low Herald

Magnus the Red for mid herald.

Magnus is good and all. But he is outclassed by all the high heralds and several of the mid heralds.

Originally posted by NemeBro
He'd easily kill Superman actually.

Even without it, his telepathic prowess is significant enough to assert control over Superman, and Magnus can survive the destruction of his body (Essentially existing as a collection of Warpstuff).

Originally posted by NemeBro
He'd easily kill Superman actually.

"Outclassed"

lern2spell

God damn Ipad...

I'll need to find an expert to make a Magnus the Red vs Wonder Woman (defining mid herald, no magic/psyker stuff vulnerability) battlezone. Also unkillability of Daemon Princes is questionable... (Draigo vs Mortation is a PIS of highest degree, though).

Planeswalkers (Magic: The Gathering) for Mid Herald collectively.

Specific characters can be adjusted as they're brought up for discussion.

And for the sake of posterity adding another T.C.G. premise here.

Endbringers (Hecatomb) for High Herald.

Yes, there's a card in the MtG system with the same name, but it used to be its own game which could arguably be considered Magic gone grimdark. Players took on the role of the Big Bad in a race to bring total annihilation to a dimension first before jumping to the next one; rinse and repeat. Heavy Lovecraft and other such mythos inspiration. WotC discontinued it about three years back, much to my dismay.
🙁

Only the old Planswalkers and Nicol Bolas would be mid herald in my opinion. Sorin and the others are meta to me. You possibly know more feat and lore wise so why do you see them as mid-herald?

Why is Arceus an Abstract? None of his feats(whether implied or actually shown on-screen) put him beyond trans at best.

Originally posted by Charlotte DeBel
I'll need to find an expert to make a Magnus the Red vs Wonder Woman (defining mid herald, no magic/psyker stuff vulnerability) battlezone. Also unkillability of Daemon Princes is questionable... (Draigo vs Mortation is a PIS of highest degree, though).

Wonderwoman is only mid herald?

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Only the old Planswalkers and Nicol Bolas would be mid herald in my opinion. Sorin and the others are meta to me. You possibly know more feat and lore wise so why do you see them as mid-herald?

Afraid I don't actually have that much knowledge of them featwise, I'm just offering a placement based on the common abilities shared amongst Planeswalkers. They're all capable of trans-dimensional travel and reality warping to some degree in their own way. It might not actually be enough on its own to grant them Herald status, but I wouldn't consider even the worst one to be lower than Meta.

Originally posted by NemeBro
Wonderwoman is only mid herald?

Originally posted by TheGodKiller
Why is Arceus an Abstract? None of his feats(whether implied or actually shown on-screen) put him beyond trans at best.