Exar Kun vs Dooku

Started by DanBrown1911827 pages

Everything on Korriban and Dromund Kaas was well worth it.

Jedi Order was most impressive during TOR era; produced lot of great warriors during this time.

Another time when Jedi Order was impressive was during Great Hyperspace War and much earlier during Force Wars.

Also, I refuse to believe that Yoda was class of his own. He wasn't effective enough to justify the hype he received. In-fact, Mace was better warrior then him.

----

Also, it is possible for Vitiate's Sith Empire to defeat Palpatine's Great Galactic Empire in a war regardless of technological disparity between them which isn't big actually. Vitiate's Sith Empire was equipped with ample technological wonders, superweapons and kick-@ss Force-users.

I tried that route, but the Galactic Empire is just a lot bigger than Vitiates one and has a vastly larger and superior navy.

Originally posted by Nephthys
I tried that route, but the Galactic Empire is just a lot bigger than Vitiates one and has a vastly larger and superior navy.

Size matters not.

Size DOES matter.

Originally posted by SJones91109
Size DOES matter.

Not in wars.

Really? Tell that to the militarily and technologically superior Germans when they were getting their asses handed to them by the overwhelming numbers of the Rooskies at Stalingrad.

It does. Vitiates Empire will be crushed in fleet engagements and then what are they gonna do? Having loads of Sith are good for ground engagements, but ground engagements depend upon the fleet to get them onto planets. Vitiates Empire has the Dread Masters and superweapons, but they cannot be everywhere at once.

The only thing that makes this a near even battle is the sheer overwhelming number of force users in Vitiate's empire, combined with the might and efficiency of the Dread Masters. Otherwise, the GE holds both the tactical advantage, as well as the superiority in numbers.

Originally posted by SJones91109
Really? Tell that to the militarily and technologically superior Germans when they were getting their asses handed to them by the overwhelming numbers of the Rooskies at Stalingrad.

Stalingrad is just one battle; Hitler made some bad decisions which led to defeat of Germans on Eastern front. In-fact, Hitler had too many enemies to contend with.

You cannot expect one great power to fight wars against several other great powers and win.

Other than the TOR-era Republic stomping the Empire, Hutt Cartel and Dread Masters at once. excellent usaflag excellent

Stalingrad is just one battle; Hitler made some bad decisions which led to defeat of Germans on Eastern front. In-fact, Hitler had too many enemies to contend with.

You cannot expect one great power to fight wars against several other great powers and win.


Except the sad fact is that the Russians didn't need the Allies when you look back at the entirety of the war. Sooner or later (thanks to the Allies tying up Italy in Africa and the Japanese, sooner), the superior numbers of the Russians would have overwhelmed the Germans. It wasn't an issue of if, but when. In this case, the GE is both technologically and numerically superior. I'd say vastly superior because of the almost 4,000 years that have passed in terms of technological advances.

Originally posted by Nephthys
It does. Vitiates Empire will be crushed in fleet engagements and then what are they gonna do? Having loads of Sith are good for ground engagements, but ground engagements depend upon the fleet to get them onto planets. Vitiates Empire has the Dread Masters and superweapons, but they cannot be everywhere at once.

Dread Masters have much greater reach with their powers then any warship. On top of this, Vitiate himself can orchestrate a ritual with aid of his minions which would consume all life on Galactic scale barring him.

Also, you are mistaken if you think that Empire will be crushed in fleet engagements; Sith Empire also have enormous resources under its disposal. In-fact, Empire's harrower-class dreadnaughts can hold their own against any dreadnaught of Great Galactic Empire. Sith Empire can also send lot of Force-users to infiltrate important assets of Great Galactic Empire to sabotage/destroy them internally.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Other than the TOR-era Republic stomping the Empire, Hutt Cartel and Dread Masters at once. excellent usaflag excellent

Situation is not so black and white. Also, storytelling is not important for the discussion at the moment.

In the context of story, an insignificant rebellion defeated the mighty Great Galactic Empire. Do the math.

Dread Masters have much greater reach with their powers then any warship. On top of this, Vitiate himself can orchestrate a ritual with aid of his minions which would consume all life on Galactic scale barring him.

He wasn't able to do it against a fragmented empire. There's little to no chance he'd be able to do it against a monster like the GE, with Palpatine at its helm. That's reaching, Legend.

Also, you are mistaken if you think that Empire will be crushed in fleet engagements; Sith Empire also have enormous resources under its disposal. In-fact, Empire's harrower-class dreadnaughts can hold their own against any dreadnaught of Great Galactic Empire. Sith Empire can also send lot of Force-users to infiltrate important assets of Great Galactic Empire to sabotage/destroy them internally.

The arsenal of the GE and more importantly, the number of technologically advanced warships they possess, will make it a slaughter if Vitiate's Empire didn't have tens of thousands of force users or the dread masters.

In the context of story, an insignificant rebellion defeated the mighty Great Galactic Empire. Do the math.

This is blatantly misleading and completely useless for you to point out seeing as how 100% of the people on this forum have seen the movies and know this is not the case. The rebels succeeded in destroying the Death Stars. That's it. The empire collapsed on itself and even then, they had more than enough capabilities to render the rebels extinct.

Originally posted by SJones91109
Except the sad fact is that the Russians didn't need the Allies when you look back at the entirety of the war.

Really?

http://ww2total.com/WW2/History/Production/Russia/Lend-Lease.htm

Originally posted by SJones91109
Sooner or later (thanks to the Allies tying up Italy in Africa and the Japanese, sooner), the superior numbers of the Russians would have overwhelmed the Germans. It wasn't an issue of if, but when. In this case, the GE is both technologically and numerically superior. I'd say vastly superior because of the almost 4,000 years that have passed in terms of technological advances.

No! Germans lost because of following reasons:-

1. Enormous amount of German resources were deployed in Europe and Africa to confront Allied Forces. USSR itself represented a gigantic target so Germany shouldn't have messed with it until or unless it would have defeated its other enemies in the war.
2. German forces were ill-equipped to deal with harsh climatic conditions of USSR; Russians took advantage of this situation.
3. Tactical blunders of Hitler; he often refused to listen to his competent generals.

Except the sad fact is that the Russians didn't need the Allies when you look back at the entirety of the war.

You damn know what I meant, we were discussing numbers.
No! Germans lost because of following reasons:-

1. Lot of its resources were deployed in Europe and Africa to confront Allied Forces.
2. German forces were ill-equipped to deal with harsh climatic conditions of USSR; Russians took advantage of this situation.
3. Tactical blunders of Hitler; he often refused to listen to his competent generals.


All of those reasons contributed to the Germans' defeated but they weren't necessary. The numbers game was going to happen.

Originally posted by SJones91109
He wasn't able to do it against a fragmented empire. There's little to no chance he'd be able to do it against a monster like the GE, with Palpatine at its helm. That's reaching, Legend.

Have you even played SWTOR?

Vitiate's grand plan failed due to Scourge's betrayal. Scourge actually set the stage for his downfall.

Originally posted by SJones91109
The arsenal of the GE and more importantly, the number of technologically advanced warships they possess, will make it a slaughter if Vitiate's Empire didn't have tens of thousands of force users or the dread masters.

Do you even have a basic idea of technological capabilities and resources of the Sith Empire? I guess not.

Originally posted by SJones91109
This is blatantly misleading and completely useless for you to point out seeing as how 100% of the people on this forum have seen the movies and know this is not the case. The rebels succeeded in destroying the Death Stars. That's it. The empire collapsed on itself and even then, they had more than enough capabilities to render the rebels extinct.

Rebels destroyed much more then Death Stars; they felled many dreadnaughts of the Great Galactic Empire as well including the famous Executor-class dreadnaught.

On the whole, Rebels performed really well against such a mighty Empire with such limited resources. Leadership is very important for success in wars; with Sidious out of the picture, Empire lost its effectiveness.

Originally posted by SJones91109
You damn know what I meant, we were discussing numbers.

All of those reasons contributed to the Germans' defeated but they weren't necessary. The numbers game was going to happen.


No! If Germany had focused only on USSR, it would have won. Germany lost because it took chances against several great powers simultaneously.

In-fact, their are many examples in history which prove that superior leadership is more important then superior numbers to win wars.

Have you even played SWTOR?

Vitiate's grand plan failed due to Scourge's betrayal. Scourge actually set the stage for his downfall.


I assure you I've played SWTOR a LOT more than you, have beaten it a LOT more times than you, and know the ins and outs of it a lot more than you. Vitiate's grand plan was theoretical. There was no proof that it would have succeeded. And it took more than Scourge's betrayal to put a dent in that plan. A LOT of things had to go against Vitiate, only one of them being Scourge.

Rebels destroyed much more then Death Stars; they felled many dreadnaughts of the Great Galactic Empire as well including the famous Executor-class dreadnaught.

The rebels destroyed a small percent of the Empire's military.

On the whole, Rebels performed really well against such a mighty Empire with such limited resources. Leadership is very important for success in wars; with Sidious out of the picture, Empire lost its effectiveness.

Yes, the hit and run tactics Vietnam War style definitely helped them destroy two death stars but they weren't "defeating" the Empire anytime soon. And you can't have Sidious out of the picture, this fight assumes everyone is involved. Stop trying to change the layout.

No! If Germany had focused only on USSR, it would have won. Germany lost because it took chances against several great powers simultaneously.

HIGHLY debatable.

In-fact, their are many examples in history which prove that superior leadership is more important then superior numbers to win wars.

Yet the GE has superior leadership, superior technology, and superior numbers. You're making my case.

SWTORE says Vitiates ritual would have succeeded.

Originally posted by Nephthys
SWTORE says Vitiates ritual would have succeeded.

If what? About 50 different things went right? I would have made the NBA had I been:

A. Not white
B. Not Jewish
C. Not under 6"2