Asajj Ventress vs. Qui-Gon Jinn & Obi-Wan Kenobi

Asajj as of TCW S5
Jinn & Kenobi as of TPM

Setting: Dathomir

Ventress in a good fight imo

Originally posted by carthage
Ventress in a good fight imo

Qui-Gon can solos via knowing makashi very well and his physical strength, with Kenobi they can win a majority.

Originally posted by Marco1907
Qui-Gon can solos via knowing makashi very well and his physical strength, with Kenobi they can win a majority.

Originally posted by Dionysus
You think Qui-Gon is stronger than Anakin or Grievous? You think Qui-Gon's knowledge of Makashi surpasses Grievous by any significant margin? If at all? 😬

Well, he may fail about using his strength properly because of his style Ataru, but Qui-Gon has more experience than Anakin or Grievous about makashi. (he sparred with Dooku like thousand times)

Grievous is also irrelavant since he is not using djem-so or juyo as well.

Originally posted by Marco1907

Grievous is also irrelavant since he is not using djem-so or juyo as well.

Grievous's blows are quite strong, sometimes the tip of his blade doesn't always reach its target.

Originally posted by Marco1907
Well, he may fail about using his strength properly because of his style Ataru, but Qui-Gon has more experience than Anakin or Grievous about makashi. (he sparred with Dooku like thousand times)

That's actually a good point. I keep forgetting Qui-Gon was also an apprentice of Dooku's, but then so was Grievous.

Ventress. I may have vouched for her off-Dathomir anyway but in a much harder fight than, say, Maul's, due to the fact she has weaker physicals than him as well as a less tactical approach to dueling. But.. on a nexus as potent as Dathomir there's no doubt in my mind she could kill these two Jedi.

Perhaps Ventress, but with more difficulty than Maul

Bump.

I want to side with the team, but I feel that Obi-Wan just doesn't really do much at this stage in his life.

Originally posted by Marco1907
Well, he may fail about using his strength properly because of his style Ataru.

Hey Marco, I found a quote about Maul in the TPM novel, it says that he was at the "apex" of skill in power. I'm curious about what you think, Was Jinn fighting Maul at his prime?

The novelization was written before TCW, kitty.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
The novelization was written before TCW, kitty.

Stick to what you said you were gonna do and nothing else, DarthAnt66. Besides, I didn't ask you and I know that, I just want his opinion.

I meant communication outside typical forum members in threads, not total abandonment on life.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
I meant communication outside typical forum members in threads, not total abandonment on life.

Noted, now let's not spam Dionysus' thread with our back and forth.

Anyway, I forgot that this was on Dathomir troubling..

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy

Hey Marco, I found a quote about Maul in the TPM novel, it says that he was at the "apex" of skill in power. I'm curious about what you think, Was Jinn fighting Maul at his prime?

Simply an outdated comment which makes no sense. How could Maul reach his full potential at the age of 22? And if that was his full potential then no idea why Sidious would invest so much time in him.

He may have been at full potential in terms of combat skill. But definitely not overall power - as in Tk and force enhanced abilities.

Especially because Maul himself confirmed that he had grown far more powerful since he was last in Sidious's presence in Shadow Conspiracy.

He might have been in his physical prime, but not in relation to the Force.