Who ordered construction of clone troops?

if you read what i put, i never said that maul was the one, i I said he was as likely to be as dooku!

and dooku is far more suited for the ordering as maul, end of discussion 🙄

Dooku could get away with it much easier. I still think Syfo-dias was tricked into doing it by Sidious. Perhaps Jango killed him, eliminating the need for lightsabers.

Jango killing syfo dias aint a bad suggestion

nope, sounds possible!

thats the best one on here so far.
And good call on your last post yerrsot!

Isn't it just possible that (since Jedi do have difficult and deadly jobs) thats its possible he died sometime around when Dooku left the order and so he picked the name based on that? Simply cuz its fresh in his mind?

It's POSSIBLE...but leaving it to chance or happy coincidence like that is very un-sith. It's more likely Dooku hired Jango to kill Syfo-Dias and be the clone model at the same time.

Dooku left after QGJ died, that's exactly ten years ago
Sifo died ALMOST ten years ago, so ... he could have taken it afterwards or so

I found this on a site.

Sifo-Dyas served as a senior member of the Jedi Council over ten years before the start of the Clone Wars. It was he who apparently ordered the Kaminoans to begin the project which would create the Republic's Clone Army. However, Sifo-Dyas was killed before the events surrounding the Battle of Naboo took place.

Whether the Kaminoans had proof of who Sifo-Dyas claimed to be remains to be seen. Neither the senior Masters of the Jedi Council nor the office of the Supreme Chancellor were aware that the Jedi Master had placed the order, and it is still unclear what purpose the army was created for in the first place...

I think it's either Dooku or Palpatine. Because Palpatine was going to create the Empire, and the clones would have been the perfect way to spark it.

nice ... a site is not canon, the contence is not to be taken as truth

contents* And I wasn't going by the site. I was just showing what it said. I gave my own generalized idea of the clones.

Originally posted by Gotwa
And I wasn't going by the site.

i think dooku killed syfo dias, assumed his name, then ordered the troopers, super sized!!!!!!

The main objection to that is that it seems unlikely that SD died AFTER the Battle of Naboo.

yer that’s what I suggested and got slated for it 😱, so the caption can’t be true else dooku would not have been working Palpatine at the time, maul would, don’t worry I’m not going back along this point 😄

I wasn't saying you were wrong, just that Obi-Wan didn't exactly say what you said, only to Mace and Yoda.

Interesting new idea I had-

Sidious/Dooku had nothing to do with ordering the clones, and Syfo-Dias simply ordered them out of a desire to do good for the republic. However, Dooku heard about it and hired Jango to kill him and be the clone model before Syfo-Dias could get back to Coruscant and tell anyone.

It's not impossible. I like to keep things simple if possible though.

I really don't think GL is that smart. o.o