Originally posted by Emperordmb
I said Kas'im being the best duelist in history was an indefensible position because the quote itself doesn't definitively state that he is, seeing as the quote said "maybe" with a few duelists before Kas'im that clearly outstrip him. In fact I was using that to explain why the last part of that quote doesn't invalidate the rest of it because it isn't definitively stating a false fact. You'll notice in my statement on CV I defended the other two parts of the statement. Or you would've noticed if you had any noticeable reading comprehension.
So you're cherry-picking to salvage Kas'im's failure. Good to know...
Originally posted by EmperordmbWhat you been saying for the past few days is everyone who can handle a lightsaber in the PT era > everyone else, because you are salty. 😬
Holy shit everyone is acting like I'm saying Kas'im>Plo just becuz mastery, when all I've been saying for the past several days is that Plo>Kas'im becuz high tier duelist in later era is stupid.
EDIT: And now you're strawmanning, Plo Koon doesn't beat Kas'im "becuz high tier duelist", he beats Kas'im because he is among the best duelists in history during the height of lightsaber technique. Goodness.
Originally posted by Aurbere
So you're cherry-picking to salvage Kas'im's failure. Good to know...
I mean holy shit, you're saying that a quote is wrong and that I disproved it by saying that something the quote doesn't even say is factually incorrect.
How ****ing thick can you be Aurbere? Well I bolded and underlined the important part of this for your convenience since apparently you couldn't pick it up from the post I actually said it on, despite me going into depth explaining the reasoning behind it:
"I'm not trying to act like an obscure sentence at the end of the quote saying Kas'im might be the greatest duelist ever means anything, as "perhaps" kinda adds too much ambiguity for it to mean much"
I expected more reading comprehension from someone among "the best of the best" tbh
Originally posted by Aurbere
Very. 🙂Anywho. Addressed already. I win. You lose. Bye bye then. 🙂
Wow you are thick and pretentious indeed. And apparently you lack faith in your arguments despite being "the best of the best" based on this pathetic cop-out.
Originally posted by Emperordmb
You win... Because I disproved the quote somehow by saying that something the quote doesn't definitively claim is wrong... And you saying you win somehow makes it so?Wow you are thick and pretentious indeed. And apparently you lack faith in your arguments despite being "the best of the best" based on this pathetic cop-out.
Focus, DMB. I don't care about Kas'im's quote about being the best. Focus on what comes before. Gosh. This isn't hard.
How do I lack faith in my arguments? Just because I'm at work and don't have time doesn't mean I lack faith lol. Silly.
Originally posted by The EllimistWe are all aware of DMB is arguing Plo Koon's status as PT duelist doesn't put him above Kas'im. But he's effectively doing so on the basis that Kas'im's credentials are so above Plo Koon to negate his era advantage, that itself he hasn't attempted to debunk. Bearing in mind that if that couldn't be proven the case, he'd have no case.
Because he isn't actually saying what you guys think he's saying, lmao.
So yeah, he's arguing Kas'im > Plo, whether he thinks so or not. 😬
Regardless, I think the only thing that matters is everything DMB is saying is wrong. 🙂