Did Lucas fail to make Anakin a compelling character?

Started by quanchi1126 pages

Originally posted by Kurk
Notice I said that I agreed that his character was unlikable in RotS. You didn't comment on his portrayal in TCW. If you don't excuse stupidity, are you admitting that your top 10 list is stupid?
My top ten isnt entirely based off intelligence. I am saying I won't excuse it but there are many traits I like in a character. He's in my top ten which shows there aren't many cool characters in all of Star Wars.

Originally posted by quanchi112
You like shitty characters.

You miss him as your apprentice, don't you?

Originally posted by Balta Skywalker
You miss him as your apprentice, don't you?
He wasn't very smart or likeable so no.

Originally posted by quanchi112
He wasn't very smart or likeable so no.

He was the only person who ever liked you.

Originally posted by Balta Skywalker
He was the only person who ever liked you.
Based on ?

Originally posted by quanchi112
Based on ?

He decided to side with you. To be with you, to act like a friend with you. While the rest of us treat you like you really are, garbage.

Originally posted by Balta Skywalker
He decided to side with you. To be with you, to act like a friend with you. While the rest of us treat you like you really are, garbage.
Again what is this based off of ? You really seem to care about what others think of you. It's an Internet forum you pile of loner shit. Continue to bring about feelings you pos.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Again what is this based off of ? You really seem to care about what others think of you. It's an Internet forum you pile of loner shit. Continue to bring about feelings you pos.

Feelings are the way we express each other. You did bring a lot of feelings with that one message.

Again, it is based off of him siding with you in everysingle thread you participated in.

Originally posted by Balta Skywalker
Feelings are the way we express each other. You did bring a lot of feelings with that one message.

Again, it is based off of him siding with you in everysingle thread you participated in.

I do not base my opinion off of feelings I base then on actual evidence. That's what separates me from yourself and the Kurks of the Internet.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I do not base my opinion off of feelings I base then on actual evidence. That's what separates me from yourself and the Kurks of the Internet.

You mean Kurk, your former follower?

I'm sorry, but you couldn't be more than a jerk.

Good day, I'm done here.

Originally posted by Balta Skywalker
You mean Kurk, your former follower?

I'm sorry, but you couldn't be more than a jerk.

Good day, I'm done here.

And you're an obvious sock from a member too cowardly to engage me from their primary account. Begone you pitiful wretch.

Originally posted by quanchi112
And you're an obvious sock from a member too cowardly to enable me from their primary account. Begone you pitiful wretch.

Ummm; excuse me? Now you believe I'm some old guy who wants to piss you on another account?

Let's add paranoid on your list of mental diseases.

Originally posted by Balta Skywalker
Ummm; excuse me? Now you believe I'm some old guy who wants to piss you on another account?

Let's add paranoid on your list of mental diseases.

You are an obvious sock but I am not surprised. Quit personally attacking because you cannot attack the strength of my position. Trek wins over Wars. Kelvin >>> Ot.

Originally posted by quanchi112
You are an obvious sock but I am not surprised. Quit personally attacking because you cannot attack the strength of my position. Trek wins over Wars. Kelvin >>> Ot.

Then what the **** are you doing on the Star Wars section of the forum, if you like the generic franchise of Star Trek?

Originally posted by Balta Skywalker
Then what the **** are you doing on the Star Wars section of the forum, if you like the generic franchise of Star Trek?
I love both. I also like to go to see the opposition. That's called being open minded. I also do not favor trek over wars across the board. The Kelvin timeline does stomp the Ot era.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I love both. I also like to go to see the opposition. That's called being open minded. I also do not favor trek over wars across the board. The Kelvin timeline does stomp the Ot era.

Oh, you're SO OPEN MINDED, BY SAYING THAT EVERYONE IS A ****ING COWARD, WHILE YOU ARE THE MOTHER****ING KING.

**** you. I'm not talking to you ever again, even if that sounds childish, I give a ****.

Originally posted by Balta Skywalker
Oh, you're SO OPEN MINDED, BY SAYING THAT EVERYONE IS A ****ING COWARD, WHILE YOU ARE THE MOTHER****ING KING.

**** you. I'm not talking to you ever again, even if that sounds childish, I give a ****.

You sound like I destroyed your fragile ego. That's another notch on my belt. I take pride in decimating the weak. Another coward too emotional to engage me further.

Originally posted by quanchi112
You sound like I destroyed your fragile ego. That's another notch on my belt. I take pride in decimating the weak. Another coward too emotional to engage me further.

You're a weird guy.

Originally posted by Balta Skywalker
You're a weird guy.
So which is it guy ? You have said you're done multiple times now but you keep coming back for more. If you're going to come back at least debate because these emotional outbursts only make you look weak.

Originally posted by quanchi112
He wasn't very smart or likeable so no.
I had to impersonate you somehow...