Can Superman Replicate Thor's glacier shattering feat?

Started by Psychotron16 pages
Originally posted by Surtur
True, but that does drive him insane right? At least temporarily. What a pussy.

He killed Doomsday later with his bare hands so he clearly developed a taste for it.

People pointing out destroying support pillars... why, do we see Thor actually destroy a whole bunch of support pillars?

Originally posted by FrothByte
People pointing out destroying support pillars... why, do we see Thor actually destroy a whole bunch of support pillars?

They're basically admitting that Superman can't really replicate the feat.

Originally posted by Psychotron
He killed Doomsday later with his bare hands so he clearly developed a taste for it.

Nah that b*tch was so traumatized by that he died 😛

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Can Superman Replicate Thor's gl

Originally posted by Silent Master
Ok, but how does that prove his heat vision can replicate the glacier shattering feat?

Because Superman can melt the ground/ice and cause instability where a domino effect will happen.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Thing is, Superman doesn't know about the pillars.

He doesn't need to. His job is to replicate the feat. He's going to blast the surface into he achieves the result. Plus he has X-ray vision.

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Can Superman Replicate Thor'

Originally posted by h1a8
Because Superman can melt the ground/ice and cause instability where a domino effect will happen.

DCEU Superman doesn't use extreme wide angle blasts, all he'd do is melt a very small hole deep into the ice

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Can Superman Replicate T

Originally posted by Silent Master
DCEU Superman doesn't use extreme wide angle blasts, all he'd do is melt a very small hole deep into the ice
He doesn't need to. Either
1) A single beam will do exactly the same as the lightning (again lightning is hot too).
Or

2) Superman will swipe his HV around.

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Can Superman Replica

Originally posted by h1a8
He doesn't need to. Either
1) A single beam will do exactly the same as the lightning (again lightning is hot too).
Or

2) Superman will swipe his HV around.

1. Heat is not the only attribute of lightning... or did you not know that?

2. So you're saying he needs to spam his HV to achieve the same result? Yeah, I agree with you there.

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Can Superman Replica

Originally posted by h1a8
He doesn't need to. Either
1) A single beam will do exactly the same as the lightning (again lightning is hot too).
Or

2) Superman will swipe his HV around.

He doesn't know about the pillars and thus has no reason to swipe his heat vision around.

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Can Superman Rep

Originally posted by Silent Master
He doesn't know about the pillars and thus has no reason to swipe his heat vision around.
Your logic is flawed. Remember this about whether he has the capacity to do so, and not will he decide to do so.

And that's assuming he needs to swipe his HV at all.

The thread is about whether or not Superman can replicate Thor's Glacier shattering feat. So far you provided no proof that he could and only a theoretical possibility of how he might possibly do something somewhat similar if he had prior knowledge that wasn't available to Thor.

Originally posted by Silent Master
The thread is about whether or not Superman can replicate Thor's Glacier shattering feat. So far you provided no proof that he could and only a theoretical possibility of how he might possibly do something somewhat similar if he had prior knowledge that wasn't available to Thor.

The thread is about his capability of doing something. Anything other than that is trolling.

Also he does not need to know about the pillars in order to damage them. Logically, if he's trying to collapse the ground (achieve the feat) then he will continue to swipe his hv until the feat is accomplished. Also He has x-ray vision. Did you forget about that?

Now let's watch you ignore these points. Everyone watch how Silent trolls.

Originally posted by h1a8
The thread is about his capability of doing something. Anything other than that is trolling.

Also he does not need to know about the pillars in order to damage them. Logically, if he's trying to collapse the ground (achieve the feat) then he will continue to swipe his hv until the feat is accomplished. Also He has x-ray vision. Did you forget about that?

Now let's watch you ignore these points. Everyone watch how Silent trolls.

In short, he can achieve the same feat by continuously spamming his HV. I think pretty much all of us are in agreement with that.

Originally posted by h1a8
The thread is about his capability of doing something. Anything other than that is trolling.

Also he does not need to know about the pillars in order to damage them. Logically, if he's trying to collapse the ground (achieve the feat) then he will continue to swipe his hv until the feat is accomplished. Also He has x-ray vision. Did you forget about that?

Now let's watch you ignore these points. Everyone watch how Silent trolls.

It's about whether he can replicate Thor's feat, something you've provided no proof for.

If he doesn't know about the pillars, there is no reason for him to even try and use HV, since he's trying to replicate a massive shockwave.

Originally posted by FrothByte
In short, he can achieve the same feat by continuously spamming his HV. I think pretty much all of us are in agreement with that.

Only, that wouldn't be the same feat. plus why would he even think of using HV in the first place since his goal is to replicate a massive shockwave?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Thing is, Superman doesn't know about the pillars.

👆

Originally posted by Silent Master
It's about whether he can replicate Thor's feat, something you've provided no proof for.

If he doesn't know about the pillars, there is no reason for him to even try and use HV, since he's trying to replicate a massive shockwave.

Only, that wouldn't be the same feat. plus why would he even think of using HV in the first place since his goal is to replicate a massive shockwave?

Thor used lightning, a form of energy blast.
Obviously Superman doesn't have lightning powers. Therefore the OP meant for Superman to achieve the same collapse of the structure.

The lightning also melted the ground Since it took a moment before the collapse. The ground didnt collapse immediately upon impact.

Superman has neither lightning powers or a magical hammer to channel it through, so why would he think to use HV to replicate an attack that caused a massive shockwave?

BTW, post a clip that clearly shows the ice metling.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
👆
X-ray vision, my dude.

In Justice League he stopped in the middle of fighting Steppenwolf and noted a shitton of survivors in the city who needed rescuing. He wouldn't have known about them and their exact locations if he couldn't see them through all the walls+distance. He'd surely know about the pillars.

Why would Superman use X-ray vision?