Originally posted by FrothByte
Josh, for f*cks sake stop trolling. It's not about being fat, stop virtue signalling. It's about being out of shape. Someone who's out of shape is obviously not going to be as strong, fast, agile, sharp or tough as that same person when they're at their peak shape.Fat Thor doesn't have the same muscle mass as fit Thor. Muscle determines strength. Are you seriously saying that a fat, out of shape Mariusz Pudianowski can bench press just as heavily as Mariusz at his peak?
There are just too many holes in your claim and too little evidence.
Bring a single feat that tells everyone here that Fat Thor is, in terms of raw strength, inferior to his normal counterpart!
Just saying, "He is less strong, because he is out of shape, because he is fat", is just plain out discriminatory and shameful TBH!
A quick google search will tell you that many fat people are stronger than thier fit counterpart.
Now, even if you prove anything. Thanos outpowering Hulk is still going to sink anything you can possible bring. Thanos>>>>Hulk, and Fit Thor has never outstrengthen Hulk with mere muscles.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
There are just too many holes in your claim and too little evidence.Bring a single feat that tells everyone here that Fat Thor is, in terms of raw strength, inferior to his normal counterpart!
Just saying, "He is less strong, because he is out of shape, because he is fat", is just plain out discriminatory and shameful TBH!
A quick google search will tell you that many fat people are stronger than thier fit counterpart.
Now, even if you prove anything. Thanos outpowering Hulk is still going to sink anything you can possible bring. Thanos>>>>Hulk, and Fit Thor has never outstrengthen Hulk with mere muscles.
Ok before I continue, I need to confirm something. Why are you concentrating only on raw strength? There's a lot more that goes into a fight and being out of shape than simple strength.
You're strawmanning hard dude. I never claimed Thor was weak because he was fat, I said he was out of shape. Yet you keep sticking to the word "fat" and limiting the criteria to "strength" as if that's the only thing that mattered.
Also, I'd like you to show proof of someone who is out of shape being stronger than their fit counterpart.
Originally posted by FrothByte
Ok before I continue, I need to confirm something. Why are you concentrating only on raw strength? There's a lot more that goes into a fight and being out of shape than simple strength.You're strawmanning hard dude. I never claimed Thor was weak because he was fat, I said he was out of shape. Yet you keep sticking to the word "fat" and limiting the criteria to "strength" as if that's the only thing that mattered.
Also, I'd like you to show proof of someone who is out of shape being stronger than their fit counterpart.
Because of the fact that we should expect Carol's attacks to be more dire to Hela. And also to not expect a Hela as OP as on Asgard.
There are many other articles like this arround the web, even some scientific ones, but I won't go into depth with science.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Because of the fact that we should expect Carol's attacks to be more dire to Hela. And also to not expect a Hela as OP as on Asgard.There are many other articles like this arround the web, even some scientific ones, but I won't go into depth with science.
That article you linked is comparing an obese person with a DIFFERENT person who's at optimal weight. It is not comparing an out of shape person from their in-shape version like what I asked. What I'm asking is for you to prove that an out of shape person is somehow stronger than they were when they were in peak condition. Same person, different fitness levels. Capiche?
As for Carol's attacks being more dire than Hela's, you're now moving goalposts. Let me bring it back to the topic at hand: When has Thanos ever beaten a Thor who was in peak condition?
Originally posted by FrothByte
That article you linked is comparing an obese person with a DIFFERENT person who's at optimal weight. It is not comparing an out of shape person from their in-shape version like what I asked. What I'm asking is for you to prove that an out of shape person is somehow stronger than they were when they were in peak condition. Same person, different fitness levels. Capiche?As for Carol's attacks being more dire than Hela's, you're now moving goalposts. Let me bring it back to the topic at hand: When has Thanos ever beaten a Thor who was in peak condition?
Okay, first thing, I just clearly proved that a person's strength isn't related to it's physical condition (being fat or being fit).
I think I have a better grasp at your argument now, so, let me see if I get you straight?
You are saying that Normal Thor is stronger because, based on visuals, he has bigger muscles and is all buffy?