is sirius really dead?

Started by envision19 pages

lol...rosebloom i agree with everything u say now 🙂 ...in the book it says lunas mum was experimenting but i dnt know if she was an actual experimentalist or not

Yeah...It really could be anything. I just wish that JK would have done more detail in these things...but she always covers it in the end, so I don't think we have to worry about anything.

Does anyone here possibly know how to get in touch with J.K. Rowling? Something like an e-mail address, so we could ask her stuff about the book... For all we know, we might be able to figure some stuff out, even if only when the book's are coming out... I'll look into it...

I am sure that even after you found out all her personal information that she couldn't possibly want you to know, I doubt that you'll learn anything new. If she didn't tell us in the book, she isn't going to tell us in the letters or whatever. Time will reveal all. And I hope IF you do contact her, don't put my name on anything because I really don't want to get arrested.

Yes, I had written to her before the fifth book had come out, yet, I had not gained anything really from the letter. I hadn't found out anything new! Yet, I did get her picture with her autograph! 😄 Sorry, that was off topic, but i just wanted to clear that up for Mormegil.

Wow, how do people actually get her information? I mean, isn't that stuff suppose to be confidential? Wow, look at what this forum had turned into.. Umm, Sirius is dead, but he is coming back. There, that has something to do with the topic.

lol thats telling them rose!! im glad someone has decided to get back to the real topic! so if ne of u have ne new suggestions as to what u think happend just let us all no please!!

You know, I have discussed the whole Sirius issue SO MUCH that I know every possible outcome. All I can do is wait for the dumb posts and ridicule them. Maybe I'll make up a New Forum called, "Harry Potter-The FUTURE!" Watch, there will already be one, but if not...LOOK FOR IT! Woot!

goody!!! im excited now! hehe

Oh yeah! Its there! I created it! So...you can go there. The chatting possibilities are ENDLESS!! MWAHAHAHA!!!

You dumb little mortals....Sirius will never die, he got knocked back into a ****ing curtain you dumbasses. Believe me when i say, that he shall be back and hes gonna kick some ass. 😠 💃 😠 💃

...Did you EVER see me say ANYTHING about Sirius being gone? Please do not dull us with your insignificant languages either. Your complete idiocy not only annoys me, but it dishonors my Forum. You may go get educated you you hopeless twit.

Err.. Deafmonkey if you haven't yet read OFTP, I suggest you do.
Hey, maybe he will live again. But please do control your emotions.. and your typing.

Right, how's this for a theory:
Maybe that veil leads to another dimension or something, and in that dimension, Harry is dead, and there is only one dimension where Harry is alive. So, Sirius gets out of the Dept. of Mysteries (disapparates) and then finds his mirror to try and communicate with Harry. Since all the other Harry Potters are dead (not survived the encounters with Voldemort), the only window the mirror can open to is the one in which Sirius was before he fell behind the veil, the dimension where Harry Potter is alive. So, Harry one day is sorting out his school trunk and remembers his broken mirror, and notices that Sirius is in there! They communicate, and then so on ... Now, criticise this all you want, it's a very bizarre theory, but remember: Nobody knows! 😎

if ur saying he gets a mirror from a different dimension and is still able to talk to the Harry from his original dimension, wouldnt he talk to all the other siriuses from all the dimensions

The case AGAINST Sirius being dead:

First of all, Miss Rowling has a tendency to introduce something in one book, which seems quite minor, which then becomes a centrepiece of the storytelling in the next book (such as Azkaban, for example). That archway is bound to come up again.

Secondly: The Thestrals. The room in which Sirius was supposedly killed contained only people who had already seen death. That was the first thing that struck me, when Sirius was hit by Lestranges magic and fell through the arch. No one else was killed. Only Sirius. So had, say, Hermione been in the room, and Sirius had really died, it would be a matter of reading in the next book if she could see Thestrals or not. Rowling is careful to make sure only Aurors (who’ve seen death) and the Death Eaters (who’ve dealt it out) were present, along with Neville and Harry.

Thirdly: In the very end of “Order of Phoenix” we hear of Dumbledores plan to keep too much weight of Harrys shoulders. We learn, that Voldemort abused Harrys love of his godfather to lure him to the Department of Mysteries. Perhaps Sirius has been asked to pretend to be dead if he got the chance, so that Voldemort could no longer use that against him. Harry can’t do Occlumency yet, he’s vulnerable to attacks from the Dark Lord.

And finally: Where’s the body? Why take us to the room, make sure we learn that the Arch-way is strange (Death?), and then toss Sirius through that, if it was easier to hand over a body with no lifesigns. Sirius has spend more than a decade in Azkaban. He could probably endure quite an ordeal.

I'm 99 % sure he'll be back, when we don't expect it.

wow!!! nice reply! i agree with you. I mean, seriously, sirius has delt with a lot of stuff. There wasn't even a body. I mean, Cedirc didn't evaporate or anything. Does anybodies have fellings on this???????

there is an entry in JK's charity book 'Fantastic Beasts and where to find them' about a veil-type creature. (I will look this up as soon as poss, it is upstairs and i am downstairs, with only limited time on the net. Could the veil be this creature?

ok, got the book, give me a sec to find the creature...

I CAN'T FIND IT!!! I saw it when I was looking up Snidgets a few days ago, I'll try again...