*sighs* he does have a point. their is no 'real' proof on what side he's on. We're going to have to wait until the final book. *angry as this is being typed* Snape could be just pure evil. I did think it was odd how he killed him...at first I thought he was evil too, but I reread it and came up with my own theory...just to think if I hadn't read it again, I would have been agreeing about Snape being evil. *smirks*
Originally posted by Saratn
*sighs* he does have a point. their is no 'real' proof on what side he's on. We're going to have to wait until the final book. *angry as this is being typed* Snape could be just pure evil. I did think it was odd how he killed him...at first I thought he was evil too, but I reread it and came up with my own theory...just to think if I hadn't read it again, I would have been agreeing about Snape being evil. *smirks*
And just to think had I not just reread the entire series instead of just book six, I am still agreeing about Snape being evil.
Look, I'm only makin this comparision because It's the only one I can think of.
People who think Snape aren't Evil, are just as wrong as people who still think H/Hr is going to happen in Canon (sorry to all H/Hr shippers I offended0
😑 H/Hr is not gonna happened. and there was never any hint towards that.
as for Snape. I don't know for sure if he is evil... because there were hints which appeled to me.
That argument he had with DD earlier... and how he got scared(?) while making that vow..
and even in the end when he didn't try to attact Harry at all.
and even the dettentions Harry had with him... compare it with what Umbridge did... 🙄
Originally posted by Tassieof course..the reason harry gives is just naive and idiotic
yeah, I agree, I'm sure there must've been another reason why DD put so much trust in Snape, than the one Harry gives at the end of the book.
(sorry for posting in the row)
Originally posted by Clovie
😑 H/Hr is not gonna happened. and there was never any hint towards that.as for Snape. I don't know for sure if he is evil... because there were hints which appeled to me.
That argument he had with DD earlier... and how he got scared(?) while making that vow..
and even in the end when he didn't try to attact Harry at all.
and even the dettentions Harry had with him... compare it with what Umbridge did... 🙄
Actually, he does attack Harry...
If I had my book right now, I could tell you the page, but I remember, he, like, threw him back with a spell or something like that.
Not that I'm taking sides about whether Snape is evil, just pointing that out. 😉
Yeah, and he wouldnt risk attacking Harry more, becuase he made the Vow to protect Draco. So if he tried to hurt Harry more, something could have went wrong and Draco might have died. Then Snape would have died because he made the Vow to protect him from harm. All Snape was thinking about was getting Draco out of there.
Originally posted by DanZeke25
Yeah, and he wouldnt risk attacking Harry more, becuase he made the Vow to protect Draco. So if he tried to hurt Harry more, something could have went wrong and Draco might have died. Then Snape would have died because he made the Vow to protect him from harm. All Snape was thinking about was getting Draco out of there.
How would attacking Harry be breaking his vow to help Draco? 😑
Ok, Snape vowed to protect Draco, and keep him from harm. And there was a huge war going on. The exit from hogwarts was right in front of him, and then he would be able to apparate Draco to safety. WHich is exactly what he did. Now what if he stopped running, started attacking Harry, and something went wrong and Draco died? Then Snape would die because he vowed to protect him.
Originally posted by Clovie
😑 H/Hr is not gonna happened. and there was never any hint towards that.as for Snape. I don't know for sure if he is evil... because there were hints which appeled to me.
That argument he had with DD earlier... and how he got scared(?) while making that vow..
and even in the end when he didn't try to attact Harry at all.
and even the dettentions Harry had with him... compare it with what Umbridge did... 🙄
JUST BEFORE YOU READ THIS BEWARE THAT I AM COMPLETELY UNDECIDED ABOUT THE WHOLE SNAPE GOOD/EVIL THING
ooh interesting sorry....just thought but what if Snape was arguing with Dumbledore cause Dumbledore told Snape that he would have to kill him to protect Draco and himself from death...i see this as something that Dumbledore would do.....which chapter is this argument mentioned..just for my piece of mind!?
Originally posted by hotsauce6548i don't remember
Actually, he does attack Harry...If I had my book right now, I could tell you the page, but I remember, he, like, threw him back with a spell or something like that.
Not that I'm taking sides about whether Snape is evil, just pointing that out. 😉