DE Luke Skywalker vs. Yoda & Revan

Originally posted by Spartan ll
Last time I checked, Revan wasn't exactly around or alive in the DE or Prequels timeline, he was around four thousand years prior to those events, doesn't get anymore Ancient than there. Therefore I classify him with all the other Sith of that time, the Ancient Sith.

Yes, well last time I canonically checked my canon calendar, the Ancient Sith died with Naga Sadow. Revan is not an Ancient Sith, Kun is not an Ancient Sith.

If Darth Sexy likes the Ancient Sith, he favors the likes of Simus, Ragnos, Ludo, and Naga. The Ancient Sith do not include Revan, so if you're going to "classify" do it right. I mean, it's not like Revan is canonically a Sith anymore anyways. Double f*ck up.

Spartan, you're an idiot for posting once, you're a bigger idiot for responding to facts with childish name calling..

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
Spartan, you're an idiot for posting once, you're a bigger idiot for responding to facts with childish name calling..

You haven't even made an argument against me besides insulting me for no reason. Shows how good you are...

Now either debate or go crawl back into the corner you came from, n00b.

@Sama:And whatever floats your boat, Sama. He's still a fanboy of the TOTJ and Kotor periods. Ive seen him arguing against Nai in another thread, he thinks Revan is on par with and can take either Yoda or Mace Windu, which is, again,complete bullshit

Originally posted by Spartan ll
Childish name calling? Maybe if you could back up YOUR remarks, then maybe a lot more people would respect you. You were the one who drew the first insult, don't chastise me because you don't have the guts to take the heat of my insults.

You haven't even made an argument or 'facts' against me besides insulting me for no reason, contradicting yourself, I see. Shows how good you are...

Now either debate or go crawl back into the corner you came from, n00b.

@Sama:And whatever floats your boat, Sama. He's still a fanboy of the TOTJ and Kotor periods. Ive seen him arguing against Nai in another thread, he thinks Revan is on par with and can take either Yoda or Mace Windu, which is, again,complete bullshit

Originally posted by Spartan ll
Childish name calling? Maybe if you could back up YOUR remarks, then maybe a lot more people would respect you. You were the one who drew the first insult, don't chastise me because you don't have the guts to take the heat of my insults.

You haven't even made an argument against me besides insulting me for no reason. Shows how good you are...

Now either debate or go crawl back into the corner you came from, n00b.

@Sama:And whatever floats your boat, Sama. He's still a fanboy of the TOTJ and Kotor periods. Ive seen him arguing against Nai in another thread, he thinks Revan is on par with and can take either Yoda or Mace Windu, which is, again,complete bullshit

EDIT: Damnit, pressed the wrong button.

Originally posted by Darth Sexy

And I'm not a dumbass. You are the one who is, since you haven't even made a relevant argument against me.

Again, either debate or go crawl back to the corner you came from, n00b.

Dude, Sexy is more respected than you are. Sexy has also admitted on many occasions that he believes Luke to be the strongest.

Originally posted by Adas
Dude, Sexy is more respected than you are. Sexy has also admitted on many occasions that he believes Luke to be the strongest.

Hell, even YOU don't like him. And you've also accused him of being tdtd before. Nai doesn't like him, Escape and Lightsnake don't like him. And they're respected debaters around here. So much for him being respected... Now are you going to make an argument against mine on what is relevant to this thread , or are you going to be like Sexy and just waste my time?

I don't dislike any one on these forums. Not even you.

Originally posted by Adas
I don't dislike any one on these forums. Not even you.

Either way, I don't really give a shit if you don't like me. I'm only here for debating purposes, not to see who likes who on the forums. And so far, all everyone's done is waste my time with everything that isn't relevant to this thread.

Not really. I used to dislike you, but I have since changed my mind. I know find you funny.

Originally posted by Adas
Not really. I used to dislike you, but I have since changed my mind. I know find you funny.

Look, are you gonna debate or are you just going to waste my time like everyone else?

Calm down.

Spartan, Nai has provided some evidence that leaves the "DE Luke vs. DE Sidious" battle put into question. Foremost among them, Luke attempted to rebel against Palpatine shortly before the confrontation on Eclipse - and Palpatine easily defeated him in their swordfight.

I don't see how Luke would have been able to improve that much. The artistic rendering of the fight also puts Leia in a glowing aura, as Palpatine and Luke fight. It should be noted, in fact, that Sidious was showing dominance of the fight - until that part of the comic.

Then wham! Sidious is put on his ass, minus his hand.

Put two and two together, and this may either be a glaring inconsistency, or Luke had help during the fight. Either way, we know for certain that DE Luke stood no chance in a Force fight against Palpatine - and required Leia and Anakin to help him conquer the storm.

Anyways...

DE Luke is at least equal to Yoda - and I'd personally put him a tier higher. That said, Yoda would give him a hell of a fight - and Revan is simply over kill. Revan may die, but Luke will most likely be slain.

Originally posted by Spartan ll
Funny, because in the 'Sion Force Storm' thread, you even admitted to not liking me. Looks like you just contradicted yourself, again.

Either way, I don't really give a shit if you don't like me. I'm only here for debating purposes, not to see who likes who on the forums. And so far, all everyone's done is waste my time with everything that isn't relevant to this thread.

Hey kid, stop the idiocy. You had some nice little points in your earlier posts, but now, its a different matter.

And please, do not call people "n00bs". In fact I'd rather have my life than know the 101 of Star Wars facts.

Alright, I trust you, Escape.

Revan goes down, and Luke puts up a good fight with Yoda.

But like I said, we don't even have proof indicating she even KNEW BM, Escape. It isn't even addressed in the comic! And Luke was glowing aswell in the beginning of the DE Series, that it says Leia was virtually the only thing on that that was of the Lightside, so that could also be why she's glowing. And Luke didn't even fell her power joined to his, so even if it did, it had very little effect, otherwise Luke wouldve felt it.

Originally posted by Spartan ll
Alright, I trust you, Escape.

Revan goes down, and Luke puts up a good fight with Yoda.

But like I said, we don't even have proof indicating she even KNEW BM, Escape. It isn't even addressed in the comic! And Luke was glowing aswell in the beginning of the DE Series, that it says Leia was virtually the only thing on that that was of the Lightside, so that could also be why she's glowing. And Luke didn't even fell her power joined to his, so even if it did, it had very little effect, otherwise Luke wouldve felt it.

Luke felt the boost. He and Leia also felt a third presence.

Originally posted by exanda kane
Hey kid, stop the idiocy. You had some nice little points in your earlier posts, but now, its a different matter.

And please, do not call people "n00bs". In fact I'd rather have my life than know the 101 of Star Wars facts.

And I DO have a life. I rarely even browse these boards. Don't tell me to get a life when I'm not the one he needs it.

I didn't come here to get insulted, I came here to debate. Now either debate with me or stop insulting me.

Originally posted by Escape81
Luke felt the boost. He and Leia also felt a third presence.

^Right there, it proves that he didn't even feel a power boost from either Leia or Anakin and didn't realize Anakin was helping till Leia told him.

Originally posted by Spartan ll
Why don't you take a look back at the first page. I was debating with Nai and minding my own business and then Sexy started insulted me for no reason.

And I DO have a life. I rarely even browse these boards. Don't tell me to get a life when I'm not the one he needs it.

I didn't come here to get insulted, I came here to debate. Now either debate or stop insulting me.

I'm not insulting you, I'm warning you to play down the language and insults, I realise that you started off with some good points, which I acknowledged, but you were too easily provoked. Please try not to be teasted so easily next time. As I said, you both wrote some good posts.