Superman vs Goku (Official Thread)

Started by Creshosk135 pages

Originally posted by Combat_Guru
You can't believe any non-canon source, any number for the Super Saiyan multiplier is made up.
Got it, don't listen to you. Read you loud and clear.

Originally posted by Combat_Guru
And Mr. pants, I didn't say the number was one hundred percent accurate, just that it was close enough.
You said that we can't prove it wrong because it was never stated. Do you know how invalid an argument that is?
Originally posted by Combat_Guru
I haven't heard your apology yet,
And You're not going to cause I'm not apologizing to a troll. Seriously. Get a clue... Check it out you'll insult me here in a second after talking about how I don't "except" your fake apologies.

Originally posted by Combat_Guru
why is everyone sucking up to this either immature or inhuman flamer???
I'm immature and inhuman? You who say that you'll treat most of the despicable people on Earth with respect and then disrespect me call me inhuman?

Originally posted by Combat_Guru
"What are you talking about moves faster than instantly?"

He couldn't escape the force field while it was solid matter, and it would have injured him if it was energy, so he had to of moved at beyond light speed, in order to escape the force field the instant it exploded, and the explosion was instant.

That's a load of garbage....

Originally posted by Combat_Guru
Creshosk, you don't know what a narcissist is,
No, its someone who's in love with themselves. A term that better fits you mr "I make the best sigs.". Not I. But thank you for repeatedly calling me that after your false claims of not judgeing me. But then you do tend to lie a lot don't you?

Originally posted by Combat_Guru
you won't except apologizing to me, and your a bad debater,
Thank you for that compliment. No seriously. Being called a bad debater who makes as many invalid arguments, who commits as many fallacies as you do, and who still refuses to provide any real proof, is a compliment.

OH, but it does make you a hypocrite though.

Originally posted by Combat_Guru
so save yourself a lot of grief and quit bashing me.
You tell me to quit bashing you after the shit you say about and to me?

Calling you a hypocrite isn't bashing you at this point in time. Because its the undeniable truth.

That's a load of garbage....

Manga volume PG 136-141.

Originally posted by Combat_Guru
Manga volume PG 136-141.
I meant your assessment of events. Not the events themselves...

Wow, I was hoping you'd be able to pick up on that at least, but I guess your grasp of the English language is weaker than I thought.

Originally posted by Creshosk
I meant your assessment of events. Not the events themselves...

Wow, I was hoping you'd be able to pick up on that at least, but I guess your grasp of the English language is weaker than I thought.

My assessment was the same as Akira's, was it not? How was it deferent? Freeza surrounded Goku in a force field, and the instant it blew up he escaped the explosion. Unless your saying he took the explosion, in which case I'll bring up this quote,

Piccolo, "He broke out of the paralyzing light with super-speed the instant it exploded."

You do know that the Daizenshuu was wrote by Akira so it's not a non-canon source.

Originally posted by Kento
You do know that the Daizenshuu was wrote by Akira so it's not a non-canon source.

Did the Daizenshuu say it was 50 times?

If I remember right yes. That's why I said according to the Daizenshuu in my post.

Originally posted by Kento
If I remember right yes. That's why I said according to the Daizenshuu in my post.

50 times faster than faster than instantly=Faster than Superman. Sorry.

I said ssj was 50 times more powerful. Speed and strength aren't scaled with power level. And Gokou still can't move instantly. You don't have to move instantly to get away from a explosion.

Speed and strength aren't scaled with power level.

Oh really, what is?

And Gokou still can't move instantly. You don't have to move instantly to get away from a explosion.

"He broke out of the paralyzing light with super-speed the instant it exploded."

Breaking out of something and getting away from an explosion doesn't equal instant movement. Gokou has never shown to be able to move instantly. If he could IT would be totally useless also. That and Adult Gohan wouldn't take 5 minutes to fly from his house to his high school.

As for power level scaling....there isn't any proof that speed or strength scale with their ki level.

Originally posted by Kento
Breaking out of something and getting away from an explosion doesn't equal instant movement. Gokou has never shown to be able to move instantly. If he could IT would be totally useless also. That and Adult Gohan wouldn't take 5 minutes to fly from his house to his high school.

As for power level scaling....there isn't any proof that speed or strength scale with their ki level.

isnt it possible he casually flies to his school?

Originally posted by Kento
Breaking out of something and getting away from an explosion doesn't equal instant movement. Gokou has never shown to be able to move instantly. If he could IT would be totally useless also. That and Adult Gohan wouldn't take 5 minutes to fly from his house to his high school.

As for power level scaling....there isn't any proof that speed or strength scale with their ki level.

Goku didn't break out of the light before it exploded, but the instant it did.

Except the farmer had a power level of 5.

Originally posted by DestinyGuy678
isnt it possible he casually flies to his school?
He didn't go ssj but he did go all out is base form when it said that. It was when he first got Saiyaman outfit and he raced Nimbus and completely left it in the dust.

@Combat_guru - You're point? Videl has a stronger ki than her father but I doubt she's going to be punching through a bus anytime soon.

Originally posted by Combat_Guru
50 times faster than faster than instantly=Faster than Superman. Sorry.
Superman can move at multiples of the speed of light. I don't get how you can simply say "50 times faster = faster than Superman."

Give us an exact number that was proven on panel. Otherwise this is more BS from a non-canon source... YOU.

Originally posted by Combat_Guru
My assessment was the same as Akira's, was it not?[b/][quote] Prove it. Post where Akira toriyama made the same assemsent of events that you did.

[QUOTE=10362615]Originally posted by Hazsekswthurmom
[B]How was it deferent?

Could it possibly be that it didn't require him to go multiple times the speed of light to acomplish?

Originally posted by Hazsekswthurmom
Freeza surrounded Goku in a force field, and the instant it blew up he escaped the explosion.
And how is that proof he's faster than light? What formula are you using to arrive at this conclusion?

Originally posted by Hazsekswthurmom
Unless your saying he took the explosion, in which case I'll bring up this quote,

Piccolo, "He broke out of the paralyzing light with super-speed the instant it exploded."

Which isn't saying that he was faster than light. Just faster than the explosion. and explosions are not the speed of light, especailly when you can see them expanding.

http://img48.imageshack.us/img48/2931/yehbiatch7zt.jpg

There's the Daizenshuu page proving ssj is 50 times more powerful.

http://bp1.blogger.com/_uGs4u3Hs_aY/R6owuxCezqI/AAAAAAAAAPc/J4vQjpRieyM/s1600-h/daizenshuu+7.jpg

As for this...Can somebody please tell me that says Tien knows the Kaioken and that it says he's an alien. I can't understand French but that's what it seems like it says to me.

Originally posted by Kento
http://img48.imageshack.us/img48/2931/yehbiatch7zt.jpg

There's the Daizenshuu page proving ssj is 50 times more powerful.

http://bp1.blogger.com/_uGs4u3Hs_aY/R6owuxCezqI/AAAAAAAAAPc/J4vQjpRieyM/s1600-h/daizenshuu+7.jpg

As for this...Can somebody please tell me that says Tien knows the Kaioken and that it says he's an alien. I can't understand French but that's what it seems like it says to me.

Decendant of an alien race. but yeah kaio ken.

Originally posted by Combat_Guru
[B]Whats to stop Goku from teleporting to another habitable planet?

Nothing. But that would count as a forfeit.

While fighting Superman is like a slug in close combat, so Goku pwns him there.

Um, no. Superman's fighting speed is far beyond anything seen in DBZ.

Z fighters can create balls of Chi, that don't have to explode, if Goku creates one big enough it can shield him.

Post a scan of him doing this.

And that lava scene is filler, Goku can and did withstand a lot more than lava.

When? Post a scan.

Ok I won't, Piccolo couldn't 'sense' it, and it would take a nano second for the beam to kill Dende before the Z fighters move an inch from that distance.

Your source for these figures? Where are your calculations? Stop just making numbers up out of thin air. And learn to quote properly, it's not hard.

Not the detonation velocity, he couldn't escape it while it was solid matter, and it would have injured him if it was energy, so he had to of moved at beyond light speed, in order to escape the force field the instant it exploded, and the explosion was instant.

What are you talking about? It was a ball of ki. Ki can do tons of weird things in the DBU, trapping someone and then exploding is not out of the question. Furthermore, it even makes sense, since DBZ characters can catch ki blasts and hold them as if they were physical objects before they explode. And you still have not provided any kind of source or reasoning whatsoever for your claim that this is an FTL feat. Simply saying it is doesn't make it so. Furthermore, what do you mean, the explosion was "instant"? It looked like a normal explosion to me. Finally, he was inside of the thing, so it wouldn't matter how fast he was moving, he would have to have taken some damage when it exploded, and just outran the majority of the energy released in the explosion.

Even if we accept your claims that:

A. The ball he was trapped in started out as matter (of which there is no evidence whatsoever)

B. The damage from the explosion was caused by it converting to energy (still no evidence, and a solid object that size, especially one strong enough to restrain Goku's movement, would release a lot more energy if its mass was converted than the explosion we saw)

Then you still have to address the rate of conversion. It could have taken several seconds to fully convert.

I apologize, it takes more force to harm Goku than it does to destroy the core of a planet, better?

Goku was never hit with that attack directly, so you're still wrong.

Cell had more energy than Goku.

So does Superman.

It took one image for #19 to absorb ALL of Yamcha's energy.

You're comparing Vegeta to Yamcha? You do realize that Yamcha is practically the most pathetic hero in the series, right?

1: They can surround him with those balls so he can't dodge.

What are you talking about?

2: Then they'll just beat him to death with the velocity of their punches, Remember Batman punched the crap out of Superman with a kryptonite ring.

Considering Goku doesn't have Kryptonite, I don't see your point. And Batman never "beat the crap out of him" with it, either.

3: Except he won't hit him, because he's too fast.

DBZ characters: Less than 1% lightspeed

Superman: At least dozens of times lightspeed

In all of those speed feats he had to gain momentum to accelerate to those speeds, so Goku is still quicker in a fight.

Blatant lie.

You can use Chi as anything, WTF?

Would that include a temporary prison to immobilize someone? Or is that the exception?


Have I finally provided enough proof, or no?

So far, all you've provided is a good laugh.

Here's some proof,

Gohan used his Kamehameha to plow through Cell's, and his Kamehameha also shielded him from Cell's.

Manga Volume #19.

That was overwhelming one beam with another, not shielding himself with it. It protected him because it was actively pushing the other beam back.

Superman's speed blitz's are far less occurring than Z fighters plowing through each other's Chi blasts.

This again? He speedblitzes practically in every other fight he's in nowadays.

And Superman isn't as quick as Goku, Superman's main speed is that of acceleration, not in hand to hand combat.

Lie. Way to ignore all of my examples.

http://i160.photobucket.com/albums/t173/EndlessMike9/Superman/supermanspeedfight.jpg

Superman's speed blitz wouldn't make him fast enough to dodge Goku's punches. Goku might not could kill him, but he could beat the crap out of him with his martial arts, quickness, agility, stamina and dexterity, toppled with the sheer speed of his hits.

Prove it.

He has super human reflexes, just not enough.

Then post a scan showing a reflex feat from Goku that's greater than Superman's. And BTW, escaping an explosion of undefined speed and then making up a bunch of crap about it doesn't count.

It's not a bio-aura it's a bio-electric field, which can easily be disrupted by enough kinetic force, and his density (Hard Body) won't save him from the sheer speed of a Super Saiyan's punch either.

Okay, let's go over this again: What's the most damage a DBZ character has ever caused with a punch? Knocking down a few small hills?

Superman has been punched across the earth, to the moon, straight through the earth, and not been hurt at all.

Goku could wail on him all day and it wouldn't do a thing.

Kryptonian's power are relative to a yellow sun, a Saiyan's how ever, is not. If Super Saiyan Goku were to teleport to lets say a red sun solar system

And he would somehow know that Superman is vulnerable to red sunlight, and where a red star was, and there would conveniently be life there with ki he could sense, and it would conveniently live on a planet with a breathable atmosphere.... see why this doesn't work?

and make a Genki Dama there, where everything is bombarded by the red son's solar radiation, and teleport back to Superman with his Genki Dama, and use it, it would be lethal to Superman even from a great distance.

Genki dama only hurts evil people. Sorry.

Say Goku didn't know Superman's powers, he'd still win because his quickness, agility, dexterity and stamina are greater at Super Saiyan.

You keep stating this, but have provided absolutely no evidence to back it up. Saying something over and over again doesn't make it true.

The life is nourished by red sun radiation, and so is the Genki Dama, no comic book character is pure of heart.

WTF? Superman took Asmodel's light of heaven attack which would have destroyed his soul had it not been pure. He was fine.

Goku does have to force to break through Superman's bio-shield, since Raditz had the strength to propel a bullet through a human, that might not have all been strength, but speed as well.

So now bullets > supernovae and galaxy-destroying attacks. 🙄

Your arguments just keep getting more and more irrational.

GT Goku is complete canon nonsense, SSJ Vegerot would annihilate any Superman.

PROVE.

IT.

Your right about the Genki Dama, it might not harm Superman anymore than a regular one in our solar system would, but Superman does not have a pure heart, only people in the DBZ universe have pure hearts because of their spirits, which Superman doesn't have, at all.[quote]

That's utterly ridiculous. Are you seriously claiming that DBZ characters are the only characters in all of fiction who are truly pure of heart? Do you realize how utterly retarded that claim is?

If you want to get technical, the exact line was "It won't harm you if you don't have evil chi". Superman doesn't have chi at all (at least not of the DBZ variety). So you're out another one.

[quote]If Raditz can generate enough speed and strength to kill a human by flicking a bullet, than Super Saiyan Goku has enough force to kill a human with as much density as Superman by flicking a god proof bullet

Wait.... what?

thats according to the science of Superman, I'll have one of my friends do the math if you tell me exactly how dense his sub atomic particles are, but I'm no scientist, if you want proof you have to provide proof. But his shield would absorb of the shock, but Goku could hurt Superman, a weakened Superman was hurt by high voltage in the Batman fight.

Key word: weakened. BTW, are you talking about Dark Knight Returns? Because that's not canon.

It doesn't matter, if Superman,however weakened he was, could be hurt by high voltage than Goku can hurt him. Provide proof that Superman is quicker than Goku in combat, please. [quote]

He fought Wonder Woman around the earth, to the sun (at least past the orbit of Mercury) and back in 1 minute and 54 seconds. And don't pull that bullshit about it not being combat speed, they were punching, dodging, reacting, and strategizing the whole time.

[quote]Remember that Goku moved faster than instantly

Okay, what? Stop making things up.

and that he became an after image.

Just like Spider-man and Kenshin.

Now if you mean Superman shakes his molecules and becomes a ghost, then nothing physical could touch him because it'd go through him, but Superman can't do that forever, and even with his molecules moving he can't lay a hand on Goku because Goku's too fast..

Goku is a snail compared to Superman. Superman could punch him in the face, give him a wedgie, cut his hair off, run to a department store and get magic markers and draw a mustache and beard on his face, then go and read the entire Library of Congress before Goku's neurons could even fire.

Get the picture?

Why is everyone dismissing the feat where Goku escaped the force field in the instant it exploded?????

Because it's unquantifiable and depends on the detonation velocity, which is unknown.

Again Superman's feats are that of acceleration

Wrong. He can move from standing still to the other side of the city in an instant, and react that fast too.

a reflex is deferent from agility, dexterity and stamina, which Goku trumps Superman in,

I believe we asked for proof, not merely a restatement of your claims.

Goku gets tired after using SSJ3 for 5 minutes, how the hell does he have better stamina? As for dexterity, Superman has rebuilt cities in seconds, manually assembling each building. Agility, well see above.

I didn't know what you meant by reflexes at first, I apologize, but Goku's start to finish speed bursts are quicker than Superman's

Prove it.

the Superman speed feats that match the force field incident are when he was traveling through open space, and didn't have to maneuver.

This "force field incident" is unquantifiable. Even if we assume the detonation velocity was 10,000 m/s (pretty much the upper limit for explosions in the atmosphere), that's still much, much less than Superman's speed.

And even if he did, Goku was 75 times faster than he was when he moved faster than instantly, (thats my super saiyan multiplier, you can't prove it wrong because his power level was never stated)

Okay, WHAT!?

You can't just make up numbers and ask other people to prove them wrong. Do you know anything about logic or debate? What if I say that Superman can move, fight, and punch at 99999999999 trillion times lightspeed squared. You can't disprove that, so I guess that means I'm right!

Goku's quicker, and he can harm Superman.

Prove it.

You can't believe any non-canon source, any number for the Super Saiyan multiplier is made up.

And Mr. pants, I didn't say the number was one hundred percent accurate, just that it was close enough.

Okay, you're just trolling now. I didn't want to believe it at first, but Creshosk is right.

No one can honestly be this stupid.

He couldn't escape the force field while it was solid matter

Prove it was solid matter.

BTW, the whole idea of a "force field" made of "solid matter" is inherently self-contradicting.

and it would have injured him if it was energy

But I thought you could do anything with chi? Your own words.

so he had to of moved at beyond light speed, in order to escape the force field the instant it exploded, and the explosion was instant.

Complete non-sequiter coupled with an unsupported assumption.

My assessment was the same as Akira's, was it not? How was it deferent? Freeza surrounded Goku in a force field, and the instant it blew up he escaped the explosion. Unless your saying he took the explosion, in which case I'll bring up this quote,

Piccolo, "He broke out of the paralyzing light with super-speed the instant it exploded."

You just shot yourself in the foot. If it's described as light, it can't be solid matter. Light =/= matter.

If I remember right yes. That's why I said according to the Daizenshuu in my post.

The Daizenshuu gave SSJ1 Goku's power level as 50 times higher than base Goku's PL in the Frieza saga. It said nothing about the other transformations, and considering some SSJ1s are stronger than others, it can't be assumed to be the same. Not to mention this is a moot point since PLs don't scale linearly with speed.

"He broke out of the paralyzing light with super-speed the instant it exploded."

What does this prove? When it exploded, he outran it. This feat is unquantifiable unless we know the detonation velocity.

Goku didn't break out of the light before it exploded, but the instant it did.

So all he had to to was outrun the explosion.

Not to mention you're using way too much of a literal interpretation of dialogue. By "instant", I highly doubt Picollo meant "no time at all". After all, when Trunks killed Frieza's men it was said to be "in an instant" but Gohan and Krillin were able to comment on it while it was happening.

Except the farmer had a power level of 5.

How does this help your point?

BTW, one final point: If the explosion was lightspeed, or anywhere close to it, then why did it stop at only a few hundred meters in size? It would have expanded across the planet and into space in a fraction of a second if it was anywhere close to lightspeed, and it wouldn't have created a lingering fireball like it did.