Superman vs Goku (Official Thread)

Started by Creshosk135 pages

Originally posted by nij-ayias
i'm not breaking the rule,

i'm comparing a skill that is regularly use against a skill that is
rarely use.

i'm comparing supes' agility to his speed.

i'm comparing supes' combat speed to his travel speed.

if i'm comparing both supes' flying speed then i'm already breaking the rules

excuse me, i'm not trying to offend or anything but if i'm breaking the rule, then NO PIS Rule hides the character's limitations or i think it is already. in my opinion,
because most characters have limitations.

You're breaking the full capacity rule. If he's proven able to do something then it doesn't matter if he's only done something 15/150 appearences or anything like that. He doesn't use his heat vision in every comic, doesn't mean he doesn't have it. He doesn't use his ice breath, super hearing or microscopic vision in every comic. He still has those powers. Your argument that he rarely uses a power so therefore he either doesn't have that power or won't use it is really grasping at straws and it breaks the full capacity rule.

He's proven to be able to do it, therefore for the purposes of fights on this board he's allowed to do it. To say otherwise is to break the rule. And your "clever"(although wrong) interpritation of the PIS rule doesn't change that fact.

So is this the only way that goku can win? Limit what his opponents can do to what you preceive him doing while goku fights at his best?

Doesn't that say something when you have to handicap your opponent to win? Like he never stood a chance in the first place. So the harder you argue to handicap superman the more it proves that Goku cannot win this fight. So go ahead keep grasping at that straw with your "clever" argument. ITs just shows how weak your position is to keep commiting the supressed evidence fallacy. Yes, that's right that's another reason your argument is invalid. It's not logically consistant and is intelectually sdishonest.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
if you know all about "KI", why you didn't know about ki level or power level that it doesn't matter how powerful the damage in the surrounding is but it's level.

flying around the place is flying not fighting.

Then I guess since Goku and the people he fights fly around spances of a couple hundred feet he's not fighting at high speed either.

So do you have any high speed combat feats that aren't turned into travel speed due to this ridiculous interpritation?

It's not fighting fast if they have to travel to do it.

Or are you going to set up a double standard and indicate your bias towards goku thus compromising your stance as an objective debator?

Originally posted by nij-ayias
[B]as long as long distance is involved it's still travel not reflexes or agility.

about superman's reacting and throwing punches while flying.

how fast is that throwing punches you were saying?

prove me by scan or author's statement because all of you didn't prove me that he's reflexes is as fast as his flying speed.

you didn't answer my question:

how rare is that superman's agility and reflexes in fighting? 1 in a 10000000000000000000000

Keep breaking the full capacity rule. Soon you'll start being reported for it.

How rare is it that Goku uses the genkidama? once or twice in his fights?

Guess that means he can't or won't be able to do it in this fight [/your logic]

How many times has a Z fighter beatin Frieza? Twice? guess that means it doesn't count.
How many times has a Z fighter beaten Cell? Once? Guess that feat didn't count.
How many times has Kid buu been beaten? Once? Guess that feat didn't count.
How many times was a planet destroyed in the manga? Twice? Guess that means they can't actually bust planets in DBZ.

Guess in the end you really don't have evidence of anything happening since any given high end feat for goku only happened once or twice. They can fly sure, they did that all the time. They don't fight very fast since they're travel long distances in fights.

Yeah your arguments work really well and are completely logical. They completely destroy your side too.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
all dragon ball's attacks have KI input,

dragon ball characters are not fighting with pure physical strength.

they always involve ki in everyway except lifting or pure physical strength, because lifting limits the amount of their ki

stop assuming, the author and writer of superman didn't point out that superman is using reflexes during that earth to sun fight.

earth to sun fight is a combination of pure physical power and travel speed not agility and reflexes.

yes, he can react when he's flying but you didn't prove it equals when fighting.

it does matter how many times because it falls under the category of experience.

superman lacks experience of combat speed which involves agility and reflexes. slower opponents could land a blow to superman.

i didn't say superman has no experience at all but goku has more experience in agility and reflexes.

how rare is that superman's agility and reflexes when fighting? 1 in a 1000000000000

To bad they don't use ki when they are punching and kicking and that their punches and kicks don't shake anything while Superman's punches have been known to create shockwaves and shake the earth.

If they weren't fighting at high speed then they would just be flying to the sun not fighting to it.

Even if you don't want to admit Superman can punch as fast as he can fly you still can't deny that Superman could dodge Gokou all day long since he has the reaction time to dodge stuff while flying or running faster than light.

To bad Superman uses his speed daily and while it's not always fighting he's proven he can do things at high speed showing off his reflexes and his reaction time. Gokou goes years sometimes without ever using his abilities to their fullest.

You know even though Cell could destroy a solar system I wonder why Akira never made Buu or SJJ3 Goku claim a similar feat, doesnt matter though since Supes wins regardless.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
[B]i know just like doomsday right?

but most of superman's fight, authors didn't stated or shown they were fighting at high speed plus humans can watch it just like lois lane.

Normal humans see DBZ fights all the time. In the DOS Doomsday fight he was just in a slugfest trying to protect metropolis, he couldn't move away or Doomsday would wreck the place. Not to mention he was exhausted from fighting for hours across hundreds of miles and that was 15 years ago.

all around the world? it involves pure physical power and as long as great distance is involved, it's still travel or flying speed.

Not if they're fighting while doing so. 🙄

This whole false distinction between "fighting speed" and "travel speed" is just ridiculous anyway. Do you think that as soon as Superman moves at super speed he magically can't fight for some reason? The only way that would work is if he couldn't react as fast as he moved, and if that was true he would be bumping into things all the time (which he doesn't).

comparing and discussing that superman's flying speed and combat speed are not at the same speed is not against no PIS rule.

if i use superman's flying speed against his flying speed, that's against no PIS rule.

They are the same speed. Do you think when he's flying super fast he becomes magically unable to land a punch or something?

he didn't use agility. remember black rock, mongul, e2 supes etc.

I'd like to hear your definition of the word "agility" if you don't think that was it.

did you really read infinite crisis and it's crossovers?

the scans you posted before, those were 13-yrs old goku's combat speed. did you really read dragon ball.

LOL. Just because something is drawn in the same style doesn't mean it's of equal speed. If that were the case, then DBZ characters aren't any faster than Rorouni Kenshin characters, who are drawn with tons of blurry speed lines and afterimages too. The point is that Superman has speed feats far beyond anything any DBZ character has ever demonstrated.

again you didn't answer my question:

how rare is that? 1 in a 100000000

Not really, it happens all the time. Just in the past month of comics I've seen tons of impressive speed feats from Superman. Not to mention that he doesn't need to use his speed all the time. BTW, the point is that he is capable of those things, so you can't say he can't/won't use them.

prove me that superman's rarely combat speed is as fast as his flying speed.

Like I said, because he doesn't constantly bump into things when he's flying at high speed.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
these are goku's combat speed in his teen, unless you can prove me that superman's combat speed equals his travel speed.

😆 😆 😆

And I suppose you can show the calculations you used to arrive at that conclusion?

it's ridiculous for because it took supes an all-star version of him to become 3x stronger.

All - Star Superman is stronger than normal Superman. So what? They're both stronger than Goku.

lifting has nothing to do with ki or power levels because lifting limits the amount of their ki or power level.

LOL WHAT?

dbz is about ki and power level not the class something..........

Stop trying to ignore the fact that Goku has no strength feats that put him remotely near Superman.

black rock hurts superman with a non-planet buster attack.

Right, because every attack that ever hurt a DBZ character also destroyed a planet. 🙄

one side of the planet to other in seconds = involved long distance, therefore flying or travel speed.

to the sun and back in less than 2 minutes = involved long distance, therefore flying or travel speed.

No, because he was fighting while flying across that distance.

This is a really pathetic logical fallacy. What you're claiming is that "If A involves B, therefore A only counts as B". Using that logic, I can say that since Baseball involves running, it's the same as track and field. 😆

prove me that supes' agility and reflexes equals his flying speed.

http://i160.photobucket.com/albums/t173/EndlessMike9/Superman/supermanspeed5.jpg
http://i160.photobucket.com/albums/t173/EndlessMike9/Superman/supermanspeed6.jpg

Just a small example.

goku is more experience in fast-pace fight than supes, why?

how rare did supes fight in fast-pace?

this is not against NO PIS Rule because it's about regularly used skill and rarely used skills.

comics is what important most not the scans.

Define "fast - pace". How fast? How many km/sec? How many fractions of a second reaction time? Your no - numbers mentality belies the fact that you are blinded by art style and nothing else.

And the scans are from the comics, so I have no idea what you are getting at with the last point.

your wrong because goku gets hurt with a KI input that is powerful than many solar system busting attacks. don't get confused, read dragon ball manga.

do you even know what "KI" is?

Do you know what "LYING" is?

No one in DBZ ever destroyed a solar system. The most they ever destroyed was a planet. Cell claimed he could destroy a solar system, but the result of his attack only created a small crater in the ground, and he's known to lie and overestimate himself anyway. Meanwhile, Superman has taken galaxy - destroying attacks and survived.

it's still flying and long distance is still involved. dont make any assumptions. prove me that his reflexes is just as fast as his flying speed.

So since long distances are involved, that automatically means that reflexes aren't? False dichotomy fallacy.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_dichotomy

when he has to?

how rare is that? 1 in a 10000000000000000

Wrong. It's actually quite often.

if that is rare, then he lacks experience than goku who regularly using agility and reflexes or combat speed.

superman rarely used agility and reflexes.

goku regularly used agility and reflexes

Goku has experience using speed at his level, which is nowhere near Superman's level. Just because it's drawn all blurry doesn't mean anything other than the art style. BTW, Superman can tag the Flash, who is more experienced at using speed than anyone else. If Superman used his full speed on Goku, Goku would be dead before he even knew what hit him.

if you know all about "KI", why you didn't know about ki level or power level that it doesn't matter how powerful the damage in the surrounding is but it's level.

Lie. You can't just make up excuses to brush off the fact that DBZ characters are hurt by blasts that only create small craters in the ground. If an attack hits a planet, and it doesn't destroy the planet, then by definition, it is not a planet - destroying attack. There's absolutely nothing in the manga (and believe me, I've read the whole thing multiple times) that states that DBZ characters can magically violate conservation of energy and make 99.99999999999% of the energy in their supposedly 'planet - destroying' attacks just disappear into nothingness and leave the rest to create a tiny crater in the ground. Not to mention that most of the time it wouldn't even make sense for them to do so, especially when the villains are concerned.

flying around the place is flying not fighting.

as long as long distance is involved it's still travel not reflexes or agility.

It is if you're fighting someone while doing so.

about superman's reacting and throwing punches while flying.

how fast is that throwing punches you were saying?

prove me by scan or author's statement because all of you didn't prove me that he's reflexes is as fast as his flying speed.

If the fact that he doesn't randomly crash into things all the time isn't enough for you, you're simply too thick to convince with reason and logic.

you didn't answer my question:

how rare is that superman's agility and reflexes in fighting? 1 in a 10000000000000000000000

Wrong. Besides, even if it were, he would still do so according to the rules.

in ki control/manipulation, it doesn't matter how much the effects in the sorrounding would be.

Bullshit. If you have an attack with enough energy to destroy a planet, that energy has to be released somehow. If it doesn't fly off into space (which happens sometimes) but instead hits the planet, it won't just cause a small crater. It will damage the planet as long as it is expended on the planet.

dragon ball manga is not DC comics, so stop saying that because the attack didn't destroy a planet, it's not as strong or stronger than a planet buster.

Except it isn't. It completely defies logic and physics for you to claim otherwise, and you have absolutely no evidence supporting your side. Furthermore, whenever an attack in DBZ can destroy a planet, everyone makes a big deal of it and freaks out (like when Vegeta used his Final Flash agaist Cell, when Goku attacked Cell with his kameheha, and Cell did the same to Goku, when Buu destroyed the earth, etc.) If every attack was a planet buster, they wouldn't freak out about those attacks specifically.

all dragon ball's attacks have KI input,

dragon ball characters are not fighting with pure physical strength.

they always involve ki in everyway except lifting or pure physical strength, because lifting limits the amount of their ki

Way to completely make things up. I'd like to see any evidence for this ridiculous theory. (Not to mention the fact that it's directly contradicted by the fact that Goku could lift the 40 tons when he transformed to SSJ1, which is an increase in ki. So obviously ki does help them lifting things). And how is lifting specifically different from any other physical task? You're using a special pleading fallacy.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_pleading

stop assuming, the author and writer of superman didn't point out that superman is using reflexes during that earth to sun fight.

Some of us don't need the obvious pointed out to us. If he wasn't "using reflexes", how could he hit his opponents or dodge their punches, or avoid obstacles?

earth to sun fight is a combination of pure physical power and travel speed not agility and reflexes.

If that were the case, he wouldn't even be able to see his opponents, let alone fight them.

yes, he can react when he's flying but you didn't prove it equals when fighting.

You have not provided any reason for us to think otherwise.

it does matter how many times because it falls under the category of experience.

superman lacks experience of combat speed which involves agility and reflexes. slower opponents could land a blow to superman.

Because he doesn't use his speed all the time, only when it's necessary. He takes hits because he can take hits, that's what the whole "Man of Steel" thing is about in the first place.

i didn't say superman has no experience at all but goku has more experience in agility and reflexes.

how rare is that superman's agility and reflexes when fighting? 1 in a 1000000000000

Wrong, yet again.

Originally posted by Creshosk
Then I guess since Goku and the people he fights fly around spances of a couple hundred feet he's not fighting at high speed either.

i'm not referring to that but to his flurry of punches, kicks and dodging.

his agility

Originally posted by Creshosk
So do you have any high speed combat feats that aren't turned into travel speed due to this ridiculous interpritation?

punches, kicks, dodging and agility.

Originally posted by Creshosk
It's not fighting fast if they have to travel to do it.

Or are you going to set up a double standard and indicate your bias towards goku thus compromising your stance as an objective debator?

so where's the agility in earth to sun fights or around the world fights?

Originally posted by Creshosk
Keep breaking the full capacity rule. Soon you'll start being reported for it.

i already asked digimark ( i think that is his name) and he said CIS is allowed.

Originally posted by Creshosk
How rare is it that Goku uses the genkidama? once or twice in his fights?

Guess that means he can't or won't be able to do it in this fight [/your logic]

How many times has a Z fighter beatin Frieza? Twice? guess that means it doesn't count.
How many times has a Z fighter beaten Cell? Once? Guess that feat didn't count.
How many times has Kid buu been beaten? Once? Guess that feat didn't count.
How many times was a planet destroyed in the manga? Twice? Guess that means they can't actually bust planets in DBZ.

i agree, but your going off topic.

about the planet busting, you need to know about how strong their ki or power levels.

Originally posted by Creshosk
Guess in the end you really don't have evidence of anything happening since any given high end feat for goku only happened once or twice. They can fly sure, they did that all the time. They don't fight very fast since they're travel long distances in fights.

Yeah your arguments work really well and are completely logical. They completely destroy your side too.

only seniors are allowed to post scan, i'm not senior.

the control/manipulation of energy in DC/dragonball are way different.

Originally posted by Kento
To bad they don't use ki when they are punching and kicking and that their punches and kicks don't shake anything while Superman's punches have been known to create shockwaves and shake the earth.

If they weren't fighting at high speed then they would just be flying to the sun not fighting to it.

i said it doesn't matter if they shake anything,

what matters most are their ki that is powerful than solar system buster and they use ki in every way except lifting.

Originally posted by Kento
Even if you don't want to admit Superman can punch as fast as he can fly you still can't deny that Superman could dodge Gokou all day long since he has the reaction time to dodge stuff while flying or running faster than light.

i don't want to admit it because you have no proof just speculation.

superman's reaction when flying can't be applied in fighting because

flying =/= fighting

no proof

superman could only dodge goku by flying at long range not by agility.

and goku could dodge superman's flying attack by agility.

did you read ginyu arc?

Originally posted by Kento
To bad Superman uses his speed daily and while it's not always fighting he's proven he can do things at high speed showing off his reflexes and his reaction time. Gokou goes years sometimes without ever using his abilities to their fullest.

yes, superman has more experience in speed when not fighting.

while goku has more experience in speed when fighting.

goku continues training everyday, even when he's dead.

Originally posted by Endless Mike
Normal humans see DBZ fights all the time. In the DOS Doomsday fight he was just in a slugfest trying to protect metropolis, he couldn't move away or Doomsday would wreck the place. Not to mention he was exhausted from fighting for hours across hundreds of miles and that was 15 years ago.

i know about DOS, that superman and doomsday are fighting at super speed yet normal humans could see doomsday.

it's fighting across the miles because doomsday hit supes with 1 punch, no agility involve in fighting across the miles.

Originally posted by Endless Mike
Not if they're fighting while doing so. 🙄

This whole false distinction between "fighting speed" and "travel speed" is just ridiculous anyway. Do you think that as soon as Superman moves at super speed he magically can't fight for some reason? The only way that would work is if he couldn't react as fast as he moved, and if that was true he would be bumping into things all the time (which he doesn't).

sorry, but your only speculating.

it's not the same unless you prove me.

Originally posted by Endless Mike
They are the same speed. Do you think when he's flying super fast he becomes magically unable to land a punch or something?

since he's flying at long distance, yes. but in agility, no.

Originally posted by Endless Mike
I'd like to hear your definition of the word "agility" if you don't think that was it.

flurry of punches

dodging

moving around his opponent in different direction

as long as there are no long distance involve.

i didn't say superman can't do that but how rare compare to goku.

Originally posted by Endless Mike
LOL. Just because something is drawn in the same style doesn't mean it's of equal speed. If that were the case, then DBZ characters aren't any faster than Rorouni Kenshin characters, who are drawn with tons of blurry speed lines and afterimages too. The point is that Superman has speed feats far beyond anything any DBZ character has ever demonstrated.

it's not about drawing, did i say that?

even DC didn't say that superman can fight in lightspeed.

if your talking about speed, see it yourself

Originally posted by Endless Mike
Not really, it happens all the time. Just in the past month of comics I've seen tons of impressive speed feats from Superman. Not to mention that he doesn't need to use his speed all the time. BTW, the point is that he is capable of those things, so you can't say he can't/won't use them.

Like I said, because he doesn't constantly bump into things when he's flying at high speed.

the point is regularly used against rarely used - CIS rule

Originally posted by nij-ayias
i'm not referring to that but to his flurry of punches, kicks and dodging.

his agility

Which don't count since they were moving over long distances.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
punches, kicks, dodging and agility.
Which don't count since they were moving over long distances.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
so where's the agility in earth to sun fights or around the world fights?
Cause obviously despite being able t omove at speeds greater than the speed of light, being able to read a library in a matter of moments, being able to catch bullets from multiple people... He's incapable of moving his arms while moving over long distances...

Originally posted by nij-ayias
i already asked digimark ( i think that is his name) and he said CIS is allowed.
CIS isn't "He only did it a few times so he can't or won't do it now." That's full capacity.

Cis is "I'm not going to kill you because its not in my nature"

Originally posted by nij-ayias
i agree, but your going off topic.
Oh I'm sorry I thought we were talking about DBZ characters capabilities ... You know, Goku?

Originally posted by nij-ayias
about the planet busting, you need to know about how strong their ki or power levels.
Goku's never busted a planet. Guess that means he can't right? [/your logic]

Originally posted by nij-ayias
only seniors are allowed to post scan, i'm not senior.

the control/manipulation of energy in DC/dragonball are way different.

Red herring. That has nothing to do with your logic being consistant and not a double standard of application of "he only did it a few times therefore he can't do it now".

Originally posted by nij-ayias
i know about DOS, that superman and doomsday are fighting at super speed yet normal humans could see doomsday.

it's fighting across the miles because doomsday hit supes with 1 punch, no agility involve in fighting across the miles.

Same applies to DBZ then. They get punched a good distence its then travel speed and not combat speed.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
sorry, but your only speculating.

it's not the same unless you prove me.

ITs called sham distinction fallacy.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
since he's flying at long distance, yes. but in agility, no.
Same aplies to DBZ then.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
flurry of punches

dodging

moving around his opponent in different direction

as long as there are no long distance involve.

i didn't say superman can't do that but how rare compare to goku.

Doesn't mater, there is long distence involved in dbz fights so its all negated into travel speed.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
it's not about drawing, did i say that?
You ARE talking about the way they're drawn. "flurry of punches" for example.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
even DC didn't say that superman can fight in lightspeed.

if your talking about speed, see it yourself

That's a mistranslation. He never said he was faster than light. He's lying any way you look at it, as Freiza was faster than him when he was matching goku...

Originally posted by nij-ayias
the point is regularly used against rarely used - CIS rule
You need to learn the difference between CIS and the full capacity rule. You're breaking the full capacity rule that states theat if they're proven to be able to do something then they're allowed to do it in the battles so long as its within character. "Not killing" is within character. Not using a power that they're proven to have or a given ability when its well withing the bounds of their morality is full capacity.

On KMC, unless otherwise stated, all vs matches containing comic characters have the no cis rule...

so as far as clark's concerned, goku has just killed lois and is teasing him about it...

Originally posted by Endless Mike
😆 😆 😆

And I suppose you can show the calculations you used to arrive at that conclusion?

All - Star Superman is stronger than normal Superman. So what? They're both stronger than Goku.

LOL WHAT?

Stop trying to ignore the fact that Goku has no strength feats that put him remotely near Superman.

Right, because every attack that ever hurt a DBZ character also destroyed a planet. 🙄

No, because he was fighting while flying across that distance.

This is a really pathetic logical fallacy. What you're claiming is that "If A involves B, therefore A only counts as B". Using that logic, I can say that since Baseball involves running, it's the same as track and field. 😆

Provide evidence from canon comics, not just playing around like that.

Originally posted by Endless Mike

http://i160.photobucket.com/albums/t173/EndlessMike9/Superman/supermanspeed5.jpg
http://i160.photobucket.com/albums/t173/EndlessMike9/Superman/supermanspeed6.jpg

Just a small example.

Define "fast - pace". How fast? How many km/sec? How many fractions of a second reaction time? Your no - numbers mentality belies the fact that you are blinded by art style and nothing else.

And the scans are from the comics, so I have no idea what you are getting at with the last point.

i answer that before.

Originally posted by Endless Mike
:

Do you know what "LYING" is?

No one in DBZ ever destroyed a solar system. The most they ever destroyed was a planet. Cell claimed he could destroy a solar system, but the result of his attack only created a small crater in the ground, and he's known to lie and overestimate himself anyway. Meanwhile, Superman has taken galaxy - destroying attacks and survived.

Since, when did cell lie?

Did gohan stops him?

Yes or No

You mean, perfect cell isn’t the strongest before gohan reaches ssj2?

The computer told cell that he will be the strongest when he absorbed no.18/no.17. You mean absorbing no. 18/ no. 17 is a lie too because cell said those statements?

Supes only absorbed mageddon’s energy because it’s anti sun’s energy that he can also absorb it the way he absorb sunlight. It’s like giving a food not receiving any attacks.

Black rock hurts supes with a non-planet busting attack, look at infinite crisis crossover : superman 223.

Originally posted by Endless Mike
So since long distances are involved, that automatically means that reflexes aren't? False dichotomy fallacy.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_dichotomy

Wrong. It's actually quite often.

Goku has experience using speed at his level, which is nowhere near Superman's level. Just because it's drawn all blurry doesn't mean anything other than the art style. BTW, Superman can tag the Flash, who is more experienced at using speed than anyone else. If Superman used his full speed on Goku, Goku would be dead before he even knew what hit him.

[QUOTE=9847964]Originally posted by Endless Mike
[B]Lie. You can't just make up excuses to brush off the fact that DBZ characters are hurt by blasts that only create small craters in the ground. If an attack hits a planet, and it doesn't destroy the planet, then [b]by definition, it is not a planet - destroying attack
. There's absolutely nothing in the manga (and believe me, I've read the whole thing multiple times) that states that DBZ characters can magically violate conservation of energy and make 99.99999999999% of the energy in their supposedly 'planet - destroying' attacks just disappear into nothingness and leave the rest to create a tiny crater in the ground. Not to mention that most of the time it wouldn't even make sense for them to do so, especially when the villains are concerned. [/B]

Until now you didn’t know that they can make their attack smaller to prevent further damage of the planet.

Originally posted by Endless Mike
It is if you're fighting someone while doing so.

If the fact that he doesn't randomly crash into things all the time isn't enough for you, you're simply too thick to convince with reason and logic.

Wrong. Besides, even if it were, he would still do so according to the rules.

[QUOTE=9847964]Originally posted by Endless Mike
[B]Bullshit. If you have an attack with enough energy to destroy a planet, that energy has to be released somehow. If it doesn't fly off into space (which happens sometimes) but instead hits the planet, it won't just cause a small crater. It will damage the planet as long as it is expended on the planet.

ok provide evidence……………

Originally posted by Endless Mike
Except it isn't. It completely defies logic and physics for you to claim otherwise, and you have absolutely no evidence supporting your side. Furthermore, whenever an attack in DBZ can destroy a planet, everyone makes a big deal of it and freaks out (like when Vegeta used his Final Flash agaist Cell, when Goku attacked Cell with his kameheha, and Cell did the same to Goku, when Buu destroyed the earth, etc.) If every attack was a planet buster, they wouldn't freak out about those attacks specifically.

This is both comics and fictional characters, physics has nothing to do with it.

I said provide evidence................

Originally posted by Endless Mike
Way to completely make things up. I'd like to see any evidence for this ridiculous theory. (Not to mention the fact that it's directly contradicted by the fact that Goku could lift the 40 tons when he transformed to SSJ1, which is an increase in ki. So obviously ki does help them lifting things). And how is lifting specifically different from any other physical task? You're using a special pleading fallacy.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_pleading

Some of us don't need the obvious pointed out to us. If he wasn't "using reflexes", how could he hit his opponents or dodge their punches, or avoid obstacles?

If that were the case, he wouldn't even be able to see his opponents, let alone fight them.

You have not provided any reason for us to think otherwise.

Is that comics?

Originally posted by Endless Mike
Because he doesn't use his speed all the time, only when it's necessary. He takes hits because he can take hits, that's what the whole "Man of Steel" thing is about in the first place.

Wrong, yet again.

it's about rarely used and regularly used in their own respective comics not about counting comics.

black rock vs superman fight isn't super speed.

e2 supes vs. e1 supes too

Originally posted by Creshosk
Same applies to DBZ then. They get punched a good distence its then travel speed and not combat speed.

ITs called sham distinction fallacy.

Same aplies to DBZ then.

Doesn't mater, there is long distence involved in dbz fights so its all negated into travel speed.

You ARE talking about the way they're drawn. "flurry of punches" for example.

That's a mistranslation. He never said he was faster than light. He's lying any way you look at it, as Freiza was faster than him when he was matching goku...

You need to learn the difference between CIS and the full capacity rule. You're breaking the full capacity rule that states theat if they're proven to be able to do something then they're allowed to do it in the battles so long as its within character. "Not killing" is within character. Not using a power that they're proven to have or a given ability when its well withing the bounds of their morality is full capacity.

provide evidence, show me plzzzzzzzzzzz, show it

Originally posted by pr1983
On KMC, unless otherwise stated, all vs matches containing comic characters have the no cis rule...

so as far as clark's concerned, goku has just killed lois and is teasing him about it...

so a character that rarely uses a skill will lose to a character that regularly uses his skill.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
Since, when did cell lie?
Time for a quick English lesson:
http://www.askoxford.com/concise_oed/lie_2?view=uk

noun 1 an intentionally false statement. 2 a situation involving deception or founded on a mistaken impression.

http://www.bartleby.com/61/52/L0155200.html
lie2, equivocate, fib, palter, prevaricate These verbs mean to evade or depart from the truth:
a witness who lied under oath; didn't equivocate about her real purpose; fibbed to escape being scolded; paltering with an irate customer; didn't prevaricate but answered honestly.

http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=lie&r=66
http://www.infoplease.com/dictionary/lie
lie1 /laɪ/ Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[lahy] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation noun, verb, lied, ly·ing.
–noun 1. a false statement made with deliberate intent to deceive; an intentional untruth; a falsehood.
2. something intended or serving to convey a false impression; imposture: His flashy car was a lie that deceived no one.
3. an inaccurate or false statement.
4. the charge or accusation of lying: He flung the lie back at his accusers.
–verb (used without object) 5. to speak falsely or utter untruth knowingly, as with intent to deceive.
6. to express what is false; convey a false impression.
–verb (used with object) 7. to bring about or affect by lying (often used reflexively): to lie oneself out of a difficulty; accustomed to lying his way out of difficulties.
—Idioms8. give the lie to, a. to accuse of lying; contradict.
b. to prove or imply the falsity of; belie: His poor work gives the lie to his claims of experience.

9. lie in one's throat or teeth, to lie grossly or maliciously: If she told you exactly the opposite of what she told me, she must be lying in her teeth. Also, lie through one's teeth.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

[Origin: bef. 900; (n.) ME; OE lyge; c. G Lüge, ON lygi; akin to Goth liugn; (v.) ME lien, OE léogan (intransit.); c. G lügen, ON ljûga, Goth liugan]

—Synonyms 1. prevarication, falsification. See falsehood. 5. prevaricate, fib.
—Antonyms 1. truth.

http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=lie

lie (v.1)
"speak falsely," O.E. legan, ligan, earlier leogan (class II strong verb; past tense leag, pp. logen), from P.Gmc. *leugan (cf. O.N. ljuga, Dan. lyve, O.Fris. liaga, Ger. lügen, Goth. liugan), from PIE base *leugh- "to tell a lie."
lie (n.)
"an untruth," O.E. lyge, from P.Gmc. *lugin (cf. O.N. lygi, Dan. l¸gn, O.Fris. leyne, Ger. Lüge, Goth. liugn). To give the lie to "accuse directly of lying" is attested from 1593. Lie-detector first recorded 1909.

He told false statments frequently. In otherwords he lied all the time.

Thus, with this and the fact that the output of enough energy to supposedly destroy two solar systems (cell and Gohan) and there was minor damage to the Earth... Logic dictates he was not telling the truth.

Also note:

http://www.m-w.com/cgi-bin/dictionary?book=Dictionary&va=trash+talk
Main Entry: trash talk
Function: noun
Date: 1981
: disparaging, taunting, or boastful comments especially between opponents trying to intimidate each other
— trash–talk \ˈtrash-ˌtȯk\ verb
— trash–talk·er \-ˌtȯ-kər\ noun

Originally posted by nij-ayias
so a character that rarely uses a skill will lose to a character that regularly uses his skill.
Unless the skill isn't good enough to compete with the natural ability combined with that person's skill.

Superman is faster, Superman is stronger, Superman is more durable, both energy and physically.

Originally posted by Creshosk
Time for a quick English lesson:
http://www.askoxford.com/concise_oed/lie_2?view=uk

noun 1 an intentionally false statement. 2 a situation involving deception or founded on a mistaken impression.

http://www.bartleby.com/61/52/L0155200.html
lie2, equivocate, fib, palter, prevaricate These verbs mean to evade or depart from the truth:
a witness who lied under oath; didn't equivocate about her real purpose; fibbed to escape being scolded; paltering with an irate customer; didn't prevaricate but answered honestly.

http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=lie&r=66
http://www.infoplease.com/dictionary/lie
lie1 /laɪ/ Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[lahy] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation noun, verb, lied, ly·ing.
–noun 1. a false statement made with deliberate intent to deceive; an intentional untruth; a falsehood.
2. something intended or serving to convey a false impression; imposture: His flashy car was a lie that deceived no one.
3. an inaccurate or false statement.
4. the charge or accusation of lying: He flung the lie back at his accusers.
–verb (used without object) 5. to speak falsely or utter untruth knowingly, as with intent to deceive.
6. to express what is false; convey a false impression.
–verb (used with object) 7. to bring about or affect by lying (often used reflexively): to lie oneself out of a difficulty; accustomed to lying his way out of difficulties.
—Idioms8. give the lie to, a. to accuse of lying; contradict.
b. to prove or imply the falsity of; belie: His poor work gives the lie to his claims of experience.

9. lie in one's throat or teeth, to lie grossly or maliciously: If she told you exactly the opposite of what she told me, she must be lying in her teeth. Also, lie through one's teeth.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

[Origin: bef. 900; (n.) ME; OE lyge; c. G Lüge, ON lygi; akin to Goth liugn; (v.) ME lien, OE léogan (intransit.); c. G lügen, ON ljûga, Goth liugan]

—Synonyms 1. prevarication, falsification. See falsehood. 5. prevaricate, fib.
—Antonyms 1. truth.

http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=lie

lie (v.1)
"speak falsely," O.E. legan, ligan, earlier leogan (class II strong verb; past tense leag, pp. logen), from P.Gmc. *leugan (cf. O.N. ljuga, Dan. lyve, O.Fris. liaga, Ger. lügen, Goth. liugan), from PIE base *leugh- "to tell a lie."
lie (n.)
"an untruth," O.E. lyge, from P.Gmc. *lugin (cf. O.N. lygi, Dan. l¸gn, O.Fris. leyne, Ger. Lüge, Goth. liugn). To give the lie to "accuse directly of lying" is attested from 1593. Lie-detector first recorded 1909.

He told false statments frequently. In otherwords he lied all the time.

so, the computer that programmed cell is lying also.

i said, provide evidence.

Originally posted by Creshosk
Thus, with this and the fact that the output of enough energy to supposedly destroy two solar systems (cell and Gohan) and there was minor damage to the Earth... Logic dictates he was not telling the truth.

did you see the word that i type before?

gohan STOPS IT!!!!!!!!!!

it's not logic, it's only your opinion............

Originally posted by Creshosk
Also note:

http://www.m-w.com/cgi-bin/dictionary?book=Dictionary&va=trash+talk
Main Entry: trash talk
Function: noun
Date: 1981
: disparaging, taunting, or boastful comments especially between opponents trying to intimidate each other
— trash–talk \ˈtrash-ˌtȯk\ verb
— trash–talk·er \-ˌtȯ-kər\ noun

Originally posted by Creshosk
Unless the skill isn't good enough to compete with the natural ability combined with that person's skill.

Superman is faster, Superman is stronger, Superman is more durable, both energy and physically.

i already showed you proof that goku can fight at lightspeed without going super saiyan and now you're saying supes is faster.

actually,all of you didn't even post a comics that will prove that his flying/traveling is as fast as his agility, your only proving it by offtopic.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
so a character that rarely uses a skill will lose to a character that regularly uses his skill.

the way you doubt superman's ability really says nothing more than you not knowing much about him at all...

Originally posted by pr1983
the way you doubt superman's ability really says nothing more than you not knowing much about him at all...

i'm not doubting, i said prove it because all he was doing is punch his enemy in a great distance then follows it with flying speed.

then all of you will said, it's agility.

i said prove it!!!!!!!!!!!!

Originally posted by nij-ayias
i'm not doubting, i said prove it because all he was doing is punch his enemy in a great distance then follows it with flying speed.

then all of you will said, it's agility.

i said prove it!!!!!!!!!!!!

so blitzing doomsday, bizarro, imperiex probes and fighting wonder woman isnt using his speed? right.

Originally posted by pr1983
so blitzing doomsday, bizarro, imperiex probes and fighting wonder woman isnt using his speed? right.

i said i know they can do it, but how rare and prove me that it's faster than his travel speed.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
so, the computer that programmed cell is lying also.
Sure was.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
i said, provide evidence.
Slothful induction fallacy.

I already provided evidence. Cell was lying. He lied frequently. talking about how he'd be undefeatable and all and then was defeated. It was merely trash talking.

I realize English isn't your strong suit, but deal with it. Cell was a lying braggart. You have no evidence that attack COULD destroy the solar system.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
did you see the word that i type before?

gohan STOPS IT!!!!!!!!!!

Yes, lets adress that shall we? Gohan countered Cell's energy, in order to do that Gohan needed to pull down the same amount. which means there was enough energy being expended to destroy the solar system twice. Now I'll accept that Gohan was controlling his ki to not destroy the planet. But Cell was certainly not trying to preserve it. According to the law of conservation of energy, energy is never destroyed so all that energy had to go somewhere. and where did it go? It made a crater. And that was it.

Face facts bud, Cell was lying again.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
it's not logic, it's only your opinion............
Deny it all you want, but logically speaking he did NOT have enough energy to destroy the solar system. Why would he? BEcause he said so?

Fine I can destroy the solar system. Now you have to believe me because I said I can. I have the same evidence to support my claim that cell has to support his. 0

Originally posted by nij-ayias
i already showed you proof that goku can fight at lightspeed without going super saiyan and now you're saying supes is faster.
No you didn't, you showed me a mistranslation. And yes Superman is faster than light speed.

Originally posted by nij-ayias
actually,all of you didn't even post a comics that will prove that his flying/traveling is as fast as his agility, your only proving it by offtopic.
Sham distinction. Quit trolling. I'm not off topic discussing superman's speed or Goku's capabilities.

You have no proof that Superman fights slower than he can travel, especially since evidence of him fighting fast was already provided.