Thor AND Wonder Woman vs Superman and Captain Marvel

Started by Zeuodin16 pages

Cap's healing factor is waaaaaay better than Superman's. He also has the stamina of Atlas and durability of Atlas. He is harder to hurt than Superman.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
He's not as compelling a character for one. Even though many of his story's elements were stolen/lifted from Captain Marvel (bald scientist nemesis, flight, a female sidekick) Superman has always *seemed* like a better character.
Both just suck to me. If I had to pick one I'd say Superman. I hate the little kid part.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Both just suck to me. If I had to pick one I'd say Superman. I hate the little kid part.
That much is obvious.

Originally posted by Zeuodin
That much is obvious.
Opinions vary.

These two reasons alone makes me think that Thor could beat anyone hes going against on team 2.

Here hes surviving attacks from an enraged celestial without any bodily damage.
http://s38.photobucket.com/albums/e139/RageOfTheGod/Thor/?action=view&current=ThorvsCelestials2.jpg

And here, he is fightiing against galder and he beats him up so bad that he destroys the moon.

http://s38.photobucket.com/albums/e139/RageOfTheGod/Thor/King%20Thor/?action=view&current=ThorvsGardner9.jpg
http://s38.photobucket.com/albums/e139/RageOfTheGod/Thor/King%20Thor/?action=view&current=ThorvsGardner8.jpg

Originally posted by quanchi112
Opinions vary.

Hey lets not argue what's stupider here: a little kid who's empowered by a wizard to become an adult with flight, superstrength, and a whole myriad of other powers granted by Greek Gods (and for some reason Solomon?) or a Thor who is clean-shaven and who inexplicably talks in Middle English even though he should speak in some dialect of Old Norse.
Comics is comics.

Originally posted by Philosophía
Because the whole point of that book was that it's supposed to contain all the other books, all the other stories and it's made quite clear that the Monitor ship was able to read it because it had infinite memory capacity. It's not ambiguous in the slightest what the book represents and what Captain Marvel/Superman did.

Yes, Superman or Thor lifting hundreds of planets would be an indication of them being insanely strong. The problem is that they didn't and passing on random hyperboles as proof of them being capable of doing it is asinine.


I'm not questioning whether or not the book had infinite pages, I know that's a fact. The point is that lifting something of infinite weight isn't possible. I'm not even going to go into whether or not the monitor ship "with infinite memory" could read it. Once you've accepted something like this as possible, you can't deny the possibility of "hyperboles" simply because they do not look right to you. When a ridiculously powerful Sorcerer hits Thor with an energy beam and he claims that it could destroy a planet, we can take him on his word. That's the powerlevel around which these guys operate.

You not wanting to accept it simply because it doesn't look the way, has nothing to do with it. There's a reasonable limit to the hyperboles, Marve didn't cross it. While I'll agree how stupid it would have been if Thor had been blasted with enough energy to kill a galaxy, there's nothing wrong with him resisting the weight of some planets. You can choose to get angry because someone else is using hyperboles, but when you're flaunting impossible feats, you are no better.

We choose when to and when not to believe in the character's words. Throwing a hissy fit because Rage is playing the same game every DC fanboy has for the last three years does not change anything.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Hey lets not argue what's stupider here: a little kid who's empowered by a wizard to become an adult with flight, superstrength, and a whole myriad of other powers granted by Greek Gods (and for some reason Solomon?) or a Thor who is clean-shaven and who inexplicably talks in Middle English even though he should speak in some dialect of Old Norse.
Comics is comics.
It's all entirely subjective. I just find the idea that it's really some little kid sickening. I love the idea of some badass warrior from a mythic realm who lives for combat.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Watch your mouth. LOL. You seem to be getting all worked up again.

Supes can have his jaw broken and his throat slashed. I could post scans of him being ko'd out because he was taken out by surprise.

Why are you repeating my point?

I would imagine that in an attempt(even a shitty one) at being true Thor fan you would have a conflicting position to respond with.

Originally posted by Spire
Superman does this.

teehee people might not like it, but that is valid.

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Yes, dur me. I saw that Phil mentioned it earlier.
Lifting Infinite Pages should still be impossible.

It's Grant Morrison and Superman. Nothing is impossible.

As for whether you choose to accept or not the validity of Superman's feat, I simply do not care. The only thing I care is to laugh at you actually comparing this instance with random mid-battle shouted "I'm taking a score of planets" silver age hyperbole.

Originally posted by Spire
Why are you repeating my point?

I would imagine that in an attempt(even a shitty one) at being true Thor fan you would have a conflicting position to respond with.

I am showing how Thor can easily break Superman's glass jaw. A hammer toss is a much more likely scenario than a nerve pinch. It's what they do in character not unlikely occurrences in comics like the godblast or t-vo.
Originally posted by Philosophía
It's Grant Morrison and Superman. Nothing is impossible.

As for whether you choose to accept or not the validity of Superman's feat, I simply do not care. The only thing I care is to laugh at you actually comparing this instance with random mid-battle shouted "I'm taking a score of planets" silver age hyperbole.

So you accept one and not the other. You wonder why people call you dc biased.

Originally posted by Philosophía
It's Grant Morrison and Superman. Nothing is impossible.

As for whether you choose to accept or not the validity of Superman's feat, I simply do not care. The only thing I care is to laugh at you actually comparing this instance with random mid-battle shouted "I'm taking a score of planets" silver age hyperbole.


Then you're laughing at yourself.
Originally posted by psycho gundam
teehee people might not like it, but that is valid.

Hopefully, Thor won't be fighting any giant robots in here.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
teehee people might not like it, but that is valid.

no its not ts mantis and her skill is on a different level compared to supermans her doing the same thing superman did doesnt mean superman can do it aswell because she is just plain better than him.
thor would godblast him before he gets a chance to do anything.

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Then you're laughing at yourself.

Hopefully, Thor won't be fighting any giant robots in here.

it's a dirty move, but it also goes along with superman's no killing policy and so forth, not saying he does it all the time but it's still a royal flush scan if i've ever seen one. if you look at it from the outside it's pretty damning evidence.

in thor's defense though, it's possible for him to whip up a vortex to defend himself and toss mjolnir in superman's face really hard or something, but CIS dictates how many times out of ten either of them attempt their maneuvers.

*shrugs*

Originally posted by quanchi112
I am showing how Thor can easily break Superman's glass jaw. A hammer toss is a much more likely scenario than a nerve pinch. It's what they do in character not unlikely occurrences in comics like the godblast or t-vo.

Which is showing Superman getting hurt. Something we already know.

It's ok though, I know you were just trying to be a true Thor fan(a shitty one that is).

Originally posted by psycho gundam
in thor's defense though, it's possible for him to whip up a vortex to defend himself and toss mjolnir in superman's face really hard or something, but CIS dictates how many times out of ten either of them attempt their maneuvers.

*shrugs*


How many times Thor would attack?

The scenario is applicable if Superman is free and Thor is attacking someone else.

😂

lol @ "glass jaw"

Originally posted by -Pr-
lol @ "glass jaw"

Most of it is pretty laughable, isn't it 🙂

Anyway, I still say 5/10.