Comic Book Martial Artist Hierarchy

Originally posted by Omega Vision
I think its a travesty that X is so high when a guy like Midnighter is so low. Both of them are ultra-h/h fighters because of special abilities, so why is X special?

Because X never got his ass kicked by a judo practitioner without his powers?

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Because X never got his ass kicked by a judo practitioner without his powers?

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Edit, **** I feel like an idiot. Sorry, I was thinking of Mister X. 😮

Still, regardless of anyone else's position on the chart if you were still wondering why Midnighter isn't higher, it's because without his enhancements he was rage stomped by peak human who knew jiu-jitsu.

Where the hell is Apocalypse?

I think Blade and Punisher to 3rd is acceptable, also Black Panther to 2nd. Against moving Moon Knight up.

Originally posted by TheTyrant
Where the hell is Apocalypse?

Originally posted by Omega Vision
He's Fourth Tier AT BEST.

👆

Originally posted by YFZ 350 I think Blade and Punisher to 3rd is acceptable, also Black Panther to 2nd. Against moving Moon Knight up.

Interesting your opposed to MK moving up, but vote for Punisher even though they have stalemated several times in H2H.

No takers on Psylocke to top tier and Drax to second?

@battlehammer,

I wouldn't say it was PIS as much as it was writing. I didn't see anything that I thought wouldn't or couldn't happen realistically.

Originally posted by dmills
No takers on Psylocke to top tier and Drax to second?

I'd support Drax to 2nd, not too sure about Psylocke (mainly due to not being very familiar with her).

Originally posted by YFZ 350
Actually I meant Blade and Punisher to be moved up to master level.

I agree.

Originally posted by -K-M-
Interesting your opposed to MK moving up, but vote for Punisher even though they have stalemated several times in H2H.

I suspect the problem might be how hes being written currently. I've seen plenty of shoiwngs that would put him in second tier but those were from earlier on.

Originally posted by AlmightyKfish
I just re-read the fight, and you're right, Cap did do very well all things considered.

Imo I still wouldn't give Cap an advantage in pure h2h, but I can see where you're coming from.

Bare in mind Taskys abilities don't make him superhuman or peak-human. Cap beat some android that memorised all of earths fighting styles but because Cap had better experience, training and stats he won. Yeah I know Taskys better than some android im just explaing the principle that copying styles doesn't neccsarily mae you superior.

Originally posted by Deadline
I suspect the problem might be how hes being written currently. I've seen plenty of shoiwngs that would put him in second tier but those were from earlier on.

Who MK? He just beat Deadpool in a sword fight and put him in the hospital 🙂

MK's suit was a factor in his defeat of DP more than skill was.

Originally posted by YFZ 350
MK's suit was a factor in his defeat of DP more than skill was.

Proof?

Exactly how was DP suppose to hurt MK?

Originally posted by YFZ 350
Exactly how was DP suppose to hurt MK?

and why couldn't he? As didn't you say in the Deadpool vs. MK thread Deadpool could easily beat him?

I thought MK's stuit was impenetrable.

So then why did you say Deadpool easily beats him then? Hmmm...