Maul Brothers VS. Mace Windu

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
True but remember Dooku did struggle against Ventress and Opress. Maul is far greater than either one of them Imo.

And Kenobi seems to have weaker force defenses than the Zabrak brothers. Neither of them will go down that easily.

But yeah I can see Mace force slam either one individually. But would be pretty difficult when they're both all over him in Sabers Imho.

This is on Felucia though. You must not forget that Dooku was in an enclosed space pressured by someone physically his superior and another skilled combatant. On Felucia offing one of them would have been way easier.

Something to consider also is Felucia is a dark side nexus.

Originally posted by Mizukage Yoda
This is on Felucia though. You must not forget that Dooku was in an enclosed space pressured by someone physically his superior and another skilled combatant. On Felucia offing one of them would have been way easier.

Something to consider also is Felucia is a dark side nexus.

That's what I try to do with my forums, is pick a setting that would be fair to the combatants.
Anyways,
Force Abilities - Mace Windu is better than Maul, IMO Savage=Windu in force abilities.
Lightsaber Combat - Mace Better than both (Seperatley)
So this matchup is about a tie, but I guess it could go either way.

I barely logged in. Yet I still seen this and felt obligated to reply. This is my opinion.

If Mace was to go against them both just saber wise"plus force" he would "eventually win barely" and i mean "barely" This is what I think.

1) "Just sabers" Mace loses, but it's close.
2) "Sabers and Force" Mace wins but barely, just barely.
3) "Straight Force, Mace wins hands down.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Then there's no point bringing up Obi-Wan's dual saber performance.

Dooku's fight would be the better example to use who according to the official site "barely" had the edge over Ventress and Opress.

Yeah, but somehow I doubt Mace'll get ragdolled across the room by Opress' first strike.

I'd like to note that right after Savage killed Adi Gallia, Obi Wan was only just able to hold his own against the brothers with a single lightsaber, so maybe this is an indication that people tend to have an easier time against multiple opponents when using 2 sabers.

But then I wonder why don't jedi always have a backup saber?

Originally posted by mnat801
I'd like to note that right after Savage killed Adi Gallia, Obi Wan was only just able to hold his own against the brothers with a single lightsaber, so maybe this is an indication that people tend to have an easier time against multiple opponents when using 2 sabers.

But then I wonder why don't jedi always have a backup saber?

Your right, if there allways so useful, they should allways have 2 sabers.

Originally posted by Col. Valerian
You people are forgetting that with his effective use of Vaapad and Shatterpoint he actually beat Sidious, a much, much more powerful opponent.

Mace, by using these two powerful and unique abilities managed to defeat someone who is his superior in both skill with a lightsaber and Force power. These two brothers are below Mace in both categories. There's nothing to suggest he wouldn't he able to take this.

👆

They seem to be forgetting this.

Both brothers combined, are still below Mace in swordsmanship.

Mace would kill them much more quickly than Sidious did, and with moderate difficulty.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Yeah, but somehow I doubt Mace'll get ragdolled across the room by Opress' first strike.

True but it's not like Mace will continually be shooting FL at Opress either.

Originally posted by mnat801

But then I wonder why don't jedi always have a backup saber?

Originally posted by Excalibur2776
Your right, if there allways so useful, they should allways have 2 sabers.

Well aside from the fact that the Jedi needs to be skilled at Jar Kai to make use of 2 Sabers, the point is still moot. Because even if Dual Sabers are not more useful it would still make sense for all Jedi to carry a back up Lightsaber. And yet they don't.

I still like to think that Lightsabers are relatively rare and not just handed out like pencils. Hence the whole "This weapon is your life" lecture and the reason Ashoka was freaking out when she lost hers one episode.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
True but it's not like Mace will continually be shooting FL at Opress either.

Well aside from the fact that the Jedi needs to be skilled at Jar Kai to make use of 2 Sabers, the point is still moot. Because even if Dual Sabers are not more useful it would still make sense for all Jedi to carry a back up Lightsaber. And yet they don't.

I still like to think that Lightsabers are relatively rare and not just handed out like pencils. Hence the whole "This weapon is your life" lecture and the reason Ashoka was freaking out when she lost hers one episode.

Good point, lol. But he should still be able to wreck Opress in a lightsaber duel, even with Maul as back-up. Mace is on another level from those two imo.

I think thats it. Each lightsaber requires a crystal that the Jedi iirc carves out themselves and is pretty rare.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Good point, lol. But he should still be able to wreck Opress in a lightsaber duel, even with Maul as back-up. Mace is on another level from those two imo.

True but then Dooku was on another level to Ventress/Opress individually. But both together were pushing him (in close quarters) despite his far superior force powers.

Comparing that to this fight, I'd give Dooku the edge over Mace in Force powers. Whilst Mace is a stronger and more powerful Saber duelist than Dooku, I wouldn't think he's miles above him.

But then there's Maul who is on another level to Opress/Ventress Imo. Maul alone could be a rival for Dooku in pure Saber combat Imho.

Originally posted by |nvictu§
Both brothers combined, are still below Mace in swordsmanship.

Mace would kill them much more quickly than Sidious did, and with moderate difficulty.

How are Dooku's force powers above Mace's?

Also how is Maul "FAR" superior compared to Opress and Ventress?

Mace shows comparable TK powers to Dooku and Opress in "Liberty On Ryloth," obliterating droids with a shockwave, pushing an AT-TE off a cliff, and crushing an AAT tank with a massive door.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
Mace shows comparable TK powers to Dooku and Opress in "Liberty On Ryloth," obliterating droids with a shockwave, pushing an AT-TE off a cliff, and crushing an AAT tank with a massive door.

It regularly circulated around KMC that the microseries depicted "real Jedi" (Lucas's own words, apparently). And while the show enjoys T-canon status alongside the new one, Filoni's commentary strongly implies that the microseries is disregarded entirely by Lucas.

But, yeah. His feats in the microseries are teh l33t.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
It regularly circulated around KMC that the microseries depicted "real Jedi" (Lucas's own words, apparently). And while the show enjoys T-canon status alongside the new one, Filoni's commentary strongly implies that the microseries is disregarded entirely by Lucas.

But, yeah. His feats in the microseries are teh l33t.

So basically to them its Non-Canon? 😖

EDIT

Originally posted by The_Tempest
It regularly circulated around KMC that the microseries depicted "real Jedi" (Lucas's own words, apparently). And while the show enjoys T-canon status alongside the new one, Filoni's commentary strongly implies that the microseries is disregarded entirely by Lucas.

Aside from Windu's perfomance against Sidious, he and Dooku do have comparable feats, but for some reason, I believe Lucas intended for Windu to be above Dooku. I know I can't use that in a vs. forum, but just saying.

As for the thread, I think Windu takes it after a hard fight. If this is Windu with the same amp he received when he fought Sidious, then he stomps.