Just remember, the Jedi team Grievous beat in the cartoon were:
a.) Primarily no-name fodder.
and
b.) Per Mundi, were "exhausted"(thanks to DP for reminding me of that.)
In fact, cartoon Grievous never really beat any Jedi of note, without fairly extreme situational circumstances aiding him.
CG Grievous, on the other hand, has consistently shown that he is skillful enough to contend with nearly any noteworthy Jedi in sabers.
Originally posted by Jedi MomFodder Jedi are completely inconsequential. Mundi and Shaak Ti are also inconsequential, given that they were "exhausted" at the time. Go run 10 miles, then try to beat your best 40 yard dash time immediately afterward. Ain't gonna happen.
And I still can't wrap my head around how Fisto>five exhausted Jedi, two of them Mundi/Ti.
Even when she was fresh, Shaak Ti was hard-pressed to defeat a single Magnaguard during Grievous' siege on Courscant. That alone should tell you where she stands in comparison to the General himself.
Originally posted by Jedi Momhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=64-3talVkUA
Can you link me to the video where she fights this Magnaguard? Don't think I've seen it.
Thanks.
That's why I'd rather use the quote. It specifically states she's on Grievous' level if not above. It's likely she had a harder time with the Magnaguard on the train just as Windu had a hard time with Grievous on the train. When she fought the Magnaguard on the ground she destroyed it pretty quickly.
Originally posted by Galan007
Feats trump statements. That said, we've seen where Shaak Ti's skills stand. One Magnaguard gave her hell. Granted, that Magnaguard was obviously of a higher level than most, but still, it was one Magnaguard.Here's how I see it: Fisto ≈ Grievous >> one Magnaguard ≈ Shaak Ti.
Very astute.
The only problem with your deduction, is that this thread implies both Jedi in their peak forms - and CW Shaak Ti is not her peak form.
The Shaak Ti that gave Galen "Force Titan" Marek hell, is her peak form.
Unless that game is no longer Canon, I'm surprised no one has thought to bring it up - then again, with how little most people seem to think in this place, perhaps I shouldn't be surprised. 😛
Peak-Fisto was destroyed by Sidious in 10 seconds - even with the help of Mace Windu.
Shaak Ti by comparison, gave a much better fight to an opponent who is arguably close to ROTS Palpatine in most respects.
Indeed, if this were CW Shaak Ti versus Kit - Kit would take her down quickly.
But it's not.
This is "Zip-around like lightning - *****-smack Starkiller" Shaak Ti.
And against her, Kit himself would go down - after a very intense fight.
Shaak Ti is victorious, here.
Originally posted by §|gnWhere was it implied that this is Felucia Shaak Ti?
Very astute.The only problem with your deduction, is that this thread implies both Jedi in their peak forms - and CW Shaak Ti is not her peak form.
Anyway, if that was the intent of the thread starter(you'd think he would've specified that by now), then Shaak Ti obviously wins. RotS-Era Shaak Ti loses, though.
Originally posted by Galan007
Where was it implied that this is Felucia Shaak Ti?Anyway, if that was the intent of the thread starter(you'd think he would've specified that by now), then Shaak Ti obviously wins. RotS-Era Shaak Ti looses, though.
Where was it implied that she wasn't?
By rules, if no particular variation of the character is specified, then it is assumed the character is in her Peak-incarnation. 😮💨
And of course she owns Kit here.