Assessing Soa

Started by Selenial7 pages

I mean, even rough math shows that an AT-AT would weigh roughly 200 tonnes. One of the Rakatan statues however would weigh roughly 25 tonnes (Less than the stones Dooku lifted, LeGenD) so even if Beni was beyond mentally retarded in saying an AT-AT weighs 1000's of tonnes, his point still stands.

LOL@Stones weighing more than machines.

A stone would weigh more than a machine of equivalent size tbh. Depending on the type of stone.

Originally posted by Nephthys
A stone would weigh more than a machine of equivalent size tbh. Depending on the type of stone.

Density of Steel is three times the density of granite. If we're talking a Machine that's not meant to fit a human (or is large enough that it doesn't matter) it'll be heavier.

Shush, that uses atoms and science and shit, and ain't nobody got time for that when we could just use our opinions.

I still can't believe LeGeNd seriously thinks Soa tossing some statues is more impressive than Yoda tossing droid transport ships.

Originally posted by Selenial
I mean, even rough math shows that an AT-AT would weigh roughly 200 tonnes. One of the Rakatan statues however would weigh roughly 25 tonnes (Less than the stones Dooku lifted, LeGenD) so even if Beni was beyond mentally retarded in saying an AT-AT weighs 1000's of tonnes, his point still stands.

Your estimate AT-AT seems to be reasonable. 👆

As for the statues, I will see what I can find. But they are really heavy in real-life.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
[B]My friend, you are an idiot.

http://www.militaryfactory.com/armor/detail.asp?armor_id=293

It is not just about height and length. AT-AT is an entirely different design than the behemoth that I used as a reference.

P.1000 dimensions:

Length: 35m
Width: 14m
Height: 11m

AT-AT dimensions:

Length: 20m
Width: 4m
Height: 22.5m

Have a good look:

P.1000 is a far more heavily built vehicle design in comparison.

Oh, hello. May I interrupt your self-demolition before somebody gets hurt?

First: You may want to do your research. The Panzer VII "Maus", the largest Tank ever constructed with its 3x3x10 meters, had a weight of 188 tons. If you compare that to the AT-AT, then the part of the walker above its legs could easily weigh around 600 tons. Add the legs, and you are pretty much guaranteed to hit the 1,000 ton mark.

In fact the people over at Stardestroyer.net came up with much higher results, which means I'm probably giving you a conservative estimate here.

And, mind you, this is steel we're talking about. Not some space-age material that, apparently, easily shrugs off heavy laser fire that is pretty much capable of leveling buildings. Which could be even heavier than that.

You would need pretty big and massive stone statues to match that...

Originally posted by Nai
Oh, hello. May I interrupt your self-demolition before somebody gets hurt?

First: You may want to do your research. The Panzer VII "Maus", the largest Tank ever constructed with its 3x3x10 meters, had a weight of 188 tons. If you compare that to the AT-AT, then the part of the walker above its legs could easily weigh around 600 tons. Add the legs, and you are pretty much guaranteed to hit the 1,000 ton mark.

Lmao this is what I get for assuming LeGenD's original numbers were actually accurate.

I'm finding it difficult to actually see how anyone puts a number on it though. The AT-AT's top half would weigh over 4000 tonnes if it was steel the entire way through, but it's pretty ****ing difficult to tell just how hollow the thing actually is. I mean, it's supposed to be able to carry 40 passengers after all, along with a minimum of five speeder bikes.

Let's just agree that its heavier than the ****ing Muntuur stones. 🙂

I think Soa is badass and pretty powerful, but he's certainly done nothing to suggest he's on Luke, Yoda or Sidious's level.

Other than apparently taking the entirety of the infinite empire to enslave him?

Infinite Empire LOLtier confirmed 🙂

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Infinite Empire LOLtier confirmed 🙂

Yeah, they had like 300 planets.

And it's sort of vague as to *how* Soa "fought" the Rataka. Did he have followers? An army? Resources? Like, why wouldn't he? You could just as easily argue that it took the combined resources of the Old Republic to take down Vitiate, or the entire Rebel Alliance/New Republic to take down Palpatine/reborn Palpatine.

As far as I understand, Soa's followers are limited to those you fight in the Ops. Also, Lol@yoda having a shot vs. a giant Rakata

lol @ basically everything you say tbh.

Originally posted by Trocity
lol @ basically everything you say tbh.

Thanks for the taking the time to go and look up that image.

Unless you have it saved on your computer, which is even more sad. 😂

Could you two please stop killing this thread?

It's not even an interesting bloodshed ;_;

Trocity is a master of looking dumb each time he posts. Probably needs to stop trolling so he gains modicum of credibility 👆