Canon Luke vs Canon Palpatine

Started by darthbane777 pages

Canon Luke vs Canon Palpatine

Round 1: TCW Sheev
Round 2: ROTS Sheev
Round 3: ROTJ Sheev

All out

We don't actually know what peak Luke is capable of.

However, he likely never surpassed Sidious.

Why are people making these threads before we actually can gauge Luke/Snoke's abilities? Like come on.

Anyway, I'm fairly certain Luke would have surpassed ROTJ canon Sidious ... though he doesn't come close to either his own EU Incarnation or DE Sidious.

Originally posted by ares834
We don't actually know what peak Luke is capable of.

However, he likely never surpassed Sidious.

Peak Luke got his shit pushed in by 16 year old Kylo Ren. All incarnations of Sheev push his shit in.

Originally posted by ares834
At times I wonder if people watch these films before commenting.
Originally posted by ares834

Again I just watched the film in its entirety. Luke gets owned by young Kylo.

Dies to all of them

Sheev stomps him. Luke got put on his ass by Rey ffs.

Sheev takes this.

If we take Hamil at his word his prime was RotJ.

He gets wrecked all rounds.

Originally posted by Lord Stark
Again I just watched the film in its entirety. Luke gets owned by young Kylo.

Originally posted by Greysentinel365
If we take Hamil at his word his prime was RotJ.

He gets wrecked all rounds.

Given how pathetic he is in TLJ I actually agree with him.

Luke's probably more powerful than Sidious based on TLJ.

How come, Ant?

Luke's illusion projection feat was next-level stuff. Granted, it was on a powerful nexus, Luke was in deep meditation, and it may have killed him, but I was really impressed by that.

He also had other cool stuff like casually blowing up the hut and toying with Kylo in sabers.

This is pure speculation though and obviously not really something that can be taken to a debate. Luke's powers are shrouded in mystery and will probably forever be left open-to-debate.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Luke's probably more powerful than Sidious based on TLJ.

Is this denial or buyers regret after spending 20 bucks on the worst Star Wars movie in history?

Luke did literally nothing. Some shitty Force illusion is not on Sidious' level. If he could actually do something to Kylo from that distance it would have been impressive, but he's there to stall Kylo. Meanwhile, Rey gets a better TK feat than anything Luke ever got.

Originally posted by Psychotron
Some shitty Force illusion is not on Sidious' level.

🙄

Great argument. I can see why you're so "respected" aroung here.

Luke exploding the stone hut casually and toying with Rey in that stick fight were impressive ish but that whole Force projection thing was too hokey and out of the parameters of what the Force does; im not saying dont go into new territory with Force abilities (which they did in TFA) im saying dont make the abilities so far out there with no tether to whats come before... having said that the couple of moves Luke had in his "duel" with Kylo pissed me off because I wanted to see so much more of that from him!!

Exactly, Kylo vs Luke should have much better than that quick exchange